Who's #1?

[Gil Dobie]

Regardless of how shitty they played today, the Griz are still the only team in FCS (I think) with a zero in the loss column.

SIU has a zero in the FCS loss column, with the only loss being FBS Marshall. SIU went into UNI and SDSU and won on the road. Montana is my #2.

[skinny_uncle]

Regardless of how shitty they played today, the Griz are still the only team in FCS (I think) with a zero in the loss column.

No, Butler is 9-0.

Certainly not saying that merits them the #1 spot.
But SIU's only loss was a three-point loss to an FBS team (not a particularly GOOD FBS team, but still).

So if I was voting (which I'm not), I'd have SIU as my #1.

Not a particularly bad team either. Marshall is 5-4 and 3-2 in Conference USA.

[clenz]

SIU
Nova
Mon
W&M
Rich

[putter]

The way I evaluated Montana -- Did ISU dominate the game to make it that close - therefore questioning the quality of the team?? No. The Griz shot themselves in the foot all day with fumbles (3 while the players were not even touched) and fumble on the 1 yard line and a TON of penalties.... therefore

1. Villanova
2. SIU
3. Montana
4. Elon
5. Richmond
6. W&M

[JMUpurplehazed]

'Nova #1 'Nova wins NC

Montana LOL

[houndawg]

'Nova #1 'Nova wins NC

Montana LOL

They make it there but lose to SIU.

[Cap'n Cat]

SIU
Villanova
Richmond
W&M
UNI

[Tailbone]

Salukis had better hope that EWU doesn't make the play-offs.

History has a way of repeating itself.

[andy7171]

1- Southern Illinois
2- Villanova
3- Montana
4- Richmond
5- Elon

SIU gets a very impressive road win to claim my #1 spot.

[89Hen]

Regardless of how shitty they played today, the Griz are still the only team in FCS (I think) with a zero in the loss column.

Butler

[Ursus A. Horribilis]

'Nova #1 'Nova wins NC

Montana LOL

The JMU guys still have a say in this?

[Mike Johnson]

At least Idaho State has a National Championship banner hanging in its stadium and comes from a conference that fully funds scholarships.

Shouldn't the rankings be about this year and not about 1981?

[GRIZ MOBSTER]

I would put SIU number 1 after they beat SDU.
1. SIU
2. Montana
3. Villanova
4. Richmond
5. App st
6. Elon

Can't put Elon up there until they prove to me they are deserving unfortunately for them they will lose against what I believe is the best team in the country right now App st. As long as they have Edwards they can beat anybody. But I will say this, those east coasters that doubt Montana, that's fine keep doubting them and underestimating them, that is fine by me, if they get on a roll they can beat anybody in the country, but keep thinking that we suck so we can shove it down your throats later.

[AZGrizFan]

1- Southern Illinois
2- Villanova
3- Montana
4- Richmond
5- Elon

SIU gets a very impressive road win to claim my #1 spot.

What? A road win at the Pocatello Dome isn't impressive to you?

[Col Hogan]

I would put SIU number 1 after they beat SDU.
1. SIU
2. Montana
3. Villanova
4. Richmond
5. App st
6. Elon

Can't put Elon up there until they prove to me they are deserving unfortunately for them they will lose against what I believe is the best team in the country right now App st. As long as they have Edwards they can beat anybody. But I will say this, those east coasters that doubt Montana, that's fine keep doubting them and underestimating them, that is fine by me, if they get on a roll they can beat anybody in the country, but keep thinking that we suck so we can shove it down your throats later.

I don't know many people who doubt the Griz are good....it's the rest of the Big Fluffy we doubt...

[AZGrizFan]

I don't know many people who doubt the Griz are good....it's the rest of the Big Fluffy we doubt...

Allow me to do a 180 for a minute:

If Richmond beat Towson by 2 points on a last second field goal, CAA apologists would be touting that as "proof of the depth of the conference".

You guys must be a bunch of fuckin' democrats....hypocrisy knows no bounds.

[Col Hogan]

I don't know many people who doubt the Griz are good....it's the rest of the Big Fluffy we doubt...

Allow me to do a 180 for a minute:

If Richmond beat Towson by 2 points on a last second field goal, CAA apologists would be touting that as "proof of the depth of the conference".

You guys must be a bunch of ****' democrats....hypocrisy knows no bounds.

3 minutes....your reaction time is slowing down with old age...

[GoApps70]

Allow me to do a 180 for a minute:

If Richmond beat Towson by 2 points on a last second field goal, CAA apologists would be touting that as "proof of the depth of the conference".

You guys must be a bunch of ****' democrats....hypocrisy knows no bounds.

3 minutes....your reaction time is slowing down with old age...

Ow my........NOT Democrats.............ow, the humanity of it all.

I believe that the top 5 should be:

1) Montana
2) Villanova
3) Appalachian State
4) SIU
5) Elon

[JayJ79]

Salukis had better hope that EWU doesn't make the play-offs.

History has a way of repeating itself.

EWU losing first round in Cedar Falls? ('05)

[AZGrizFan]

Allow me to do a 180 for a minute:

If Richmond beat Towson by 2 points on a last second field goal, CAA apologists would be touting that as "proof of the depth of the conference".

You guys must be a bunch of ****' democrats....hypocrisy knows no bounds.

3 minutes....your reaction time is slowing down with old age...

I'm trying to cram 2 hours of work into an 8 hour day.

[danefan]

The AGS poll was extremely close:

1. Southern Illinois (35) 2156
2. Villanova (27) 2145
3. Montana (27) 2095

[89Hen]

If Richmond beat Towson by 2 points on a last second field goal, CAA apologists would be touting that as "proof of the depth of the conference".

If Tiger Woods beat me by one shot by sinking a 40 footer on 18....

[ToTheLeft]

I am sure I am the only one with this top 5, but here we go...

1. SIU
2. Elon
3. Nova
4. Richmond
5. William and Mary

[ASUG8]

3 minutes....your reaction time is slowing down with old age...

Ow my........NOT Democrats.............ow, the humanity of it all.

I believe that the top 5 should be:

1) Montana
2) Villanova
3) Appalachian State
4) SIU
5) Elon

I appreciate your confidence, Homer, but it's tough to put a 2 loss team in the top 3.

[89Hen]

I am sure I am the only one with this top 5, but here we go...

1. SIU
2. Elon
3. Nova
4. Richmond
5. William and Mary

Not that far fetched, but I'm not sure what Elon has done to be #2. No wins over current ranked teams and an OOC that was a loss to Wake and wins over Davidson and Presby. IF they beat App, I can see them being #2.