GannonFan wrote: ↑Tue Jul 09, 2024 6:50 am
kalm wrote: ↑Tue Jul 09, 2024 6:11 am
We’ve already lost a bit of our democratic republic thanks to recent SCOTUS rulings.
Jan 6th and the fake electors scheme showed a willingness by far too many to subvert the rule of law and the constitution.
Project 2025 takes us further away.
Not just Trump but who he’d pick to administer his desires would increase the threat. And it would be about HIS desires rather than the constitution or will of the people.
The far right has insisted we are not a democracy for years. To them, we are constitutional republic. That’s what Hungary is. People still vote there but the results are baked in through various laws, the courts, and media control. This is literally and transparently the Republican’s very public agenda.
If, as you stated, “policies and the direction for the country are always impacted by the Presidents in charge” those can chip away at the foundations of our democratic republic. I sincerely hope you’re right and that our system of checks and balances holds up but it’s all a little too close for comfort me. And it’s already started in many quarters.
Now you're slipping into hyperbole.
First of all, we haven't lost any of our democratic republic through recent SCOTUS rulings. You can make an argument about Citizen's if you want, but that was 14 years ago now and we're still hanging in there. Chevron was a problematic ruling when it itself overturned even longer precedent and it's been chipped away at almost since it came down. And Chevron was only needed, or thought to be needed, because Congress has been negligent for decades now when it comes to actually legislating and passing/modifying laws. And Roe and abortion are going to be issues no one will agree on until we have a technological breakthrough and can make artificial wombs that can accept fetuses at conception or soon after. So basically, no time soon.
But
what this country is, a free democratic republic, hasn't changed and will not change with four years of a lame-duck Trump presidency. There's no time to do that, and he wouldn't have the means to do that, even if he brings in every sycophant he can find. Courts, like they did in Trump's first round and they've done to Biden as well, will tie up a lot of things. Trump couldn't do a fraction of what he wanted to do on immigration thanks to multiple injunctions, just like Biden hasn't been able to eradicate student debt with a flick of his pen. And if anything, the most current SCOTUS rulings further emphasize that - the Executive branch can't do the work of other branches, most especially the legislative branch. If Congress wants something done they need to pass laws to get those things done. The system of checks and balances are very much in place.
So if the laws and the courts aren't rigged and baking the results of elections, as you contend, then the last thing on your list is media control. No one anywhere could possibly contend that Trump has any control of the media. Fox is one media outlet, and it's always been right of center, and even they weren't lockstep with everything Trump did in his first term. But the wide swath of other media is nowhere close to being able to be controlled by Trump. Heck, given the current controversy with a compliant media hiding much of Biden's infirmities for the past two years, if not longer, all in the hope of keeping him a strong enough candidate to beat Trump in the next election, I would be far more worried about a left-wing takeover of the media than anything Trump could do.
Come 2028, we'll have an election that won't involve Trump or Biden, and we'll have that election, and then one after it every four years, and the democratic republic we have now will endure for years to come. Sometimes Democrats will win, sometimes Republicans will win, and the country will continue. It's fine to be vigilant and protective about our country and its foundations, as long as that doesn't slip into hyperbolic paranoia.