EC(b) Explained With Maps

[kalm]

Two days after Minnesota hosts South Dakota State at TCF Bank Stadium on Thursday, Aug. 29, North Dakota State will "host" Butler at Target Field on Saturday, Aug. 31. TCF Bank Stadium is roughly 3,000 feet east of the Mississippi River, and Target Field is roughly 3,000 feet west of the Mississippi River.

Two FCS games. Same city. Two days apart. Different sides of the river.

While that two-game set is a 50-50 geographical split, the rest of the 2019 schedule leans heavily to the east. Seventy percent of all FCS regular-season games will be played east of the river:

https://m.herosports.com/college-footba ... tions-ahah

[93henfan]

Biggie>Tupac

[kalm]

Biggie>Tupac

This is the only serious forum remaining here and I’d appreciate no further hijacks.

(Chinook Salmon > Atlantic Salmon)

[UNI88]

Biggie>Tupac

This is the only serious forum remaining here and I’d appreciate no further hijacks.

(Chinook Salmon > Atlantic Salmon)

Dungeness Crabs > Blue Crabs

Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk

[kalm]

This is the only serious forum remaining here and I’d appreciate no further hijacks.

(Chinook Salmon > Atlantic Salmon)

Dungeness Crabs > Blue Crabs

Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk

BOOM!

[93henfan]

Dungeness Crabs > Blue Crabs

Sent from my XT1650 using Tapatalk

BOOM!

Seattle Magazine already stated that blue crabs taste better in their comparison article. The only win for dungeness was that it's bigger.

So basically, the west coast snob writer conceded that dungeness is the buffet of the crab world.

BOOM-erang.

My hijack is now over. You can have the stick back.

[kalm]

BOOM!

Seattle Magazine already stated that blue crabs taste better in their comparison article. The only win for dungeness was that it's bigger.

So basically, the west coast snob writer conceded that dungeness is the buffet of the crab world.

BOOM-erang.

My hijack is now over. You can have the stick back.

Probably a transplant...like this guy...who gives the nod to...

https://www.sfgate.com/recipes/article/ ... 244215.php

[Gil Dobie]

They all taste the same in crab cakes.

[93henfan]

Seattle Magazine already stated that blue crabs taste better in their comparison article. The only win for dungeness was that it's bigger.

So basically, the west coast snob writer conceded that dungeness is the buffet of the crab world.

BOOM-erang.

My hijack is now over. You can have the stick back.

Probably a transplant...like this guy...who gives the nod to...

https://www.sfgate.com/recipes/article/ ... 244215.php

I'm not even opening some article by a fag in San Francisco. Seattle was bad enough.

[css75]

Two days after Minnesota hosts South Dakota State at TCF Bank Stadium on Thursday, Aug. 29, North Dakota State will "host" Butler at Target Field on Saturday, Aug. 31. TCF Bank Stadium is roughly 3,000 feet east of the Mississippi River, and Target Field is roughly 3,000 feet west of the Mississippi River.

Two FCS games. Same city. Two days apart. Different sides of the river.

While that two-game set is a 50-50 geographical split, the rest of the 2019 schedule leans heavily to the east. Seventy percent of all FCS regular-season games will be played east of the river:

https://m.herosports.com/college-footba ... tions-ahah

This is probably the dullest map ever. Of course 70% of FCS games are east of the Mississippi. So are 70% if FBS due to the fact most of the population is there also. Duh.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[kalm]

https://m.herosports.com/college-footba ... tions-ahah

This is probably the dullest map ever. Of course 70% of FCS games are east of the Mississippi. So are 70% if FBS due to the fact most of the population is there also. Duh.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

CSS, some people have a tough time understanding how geography effects polls, national awards, the need to schedule DII’s and multiple FBS games, etc. EG: 70% of your sports writers and coaches/SID’s who vote in the polls couldn’t find Pokafellow on a map.

Consider this a refresher.

[dbackjon]

This is probably the dullest map ever. Of course 70% of FCS games are east of the Mississippi. So are 70% if FBS due to the fact most of the population is there also. Duh.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

CSS, some people have a tough time understanding how geography effects polls, national awards, the need to schedule DII’s and multiple FBS games, etc. EG: 70% of your sports writers and coaches/SID’s who vote in the polls couldn’t find Pokafellow on a map.

Consider this a refresher.

Also - the people that say that since Montana borders the Dakotas, the Montana schools and the Dakota schools must be close to each other.

[89Hen]

CSS, some people have a tough time understanding how geography effects polls, national awards, the need to schedule DII’s and multiple FBS games, etc. EG: 70% of your sports writers and coaches/SID’s who vote in the polls couldn’t find Pokafellow on a map.

Consider this a refresher.

Not sure I understand your point

Payton Award Winners
2017 Jeremiah Briscoe Sam Houston State
2016 Jeremiah Briscoe Sam Houston State
2015 Cooper Kupp Eastern Washington
2013 Jimmy Garoppolo Eastern Illinois
2011 Bo Levi Mitchell Eastern Washington
2010 Jeremy Moses Stephen F. Austin

Buchanan Award Winners
2018 Zach Hall Southeast Missouri State
2016 Karter Schult Northern Iowa
2014 Kyle Emanuel North Dakota State
2013 Brad Daly Montana State
2012 Caleb Schreibeis Montana State
2010 J. C. Sherritt Eastern Washington

Pre-Season I-AA Poll
1. North Dakota State
3. South Dakota State
4. Eastern Washington
5. UC Davis
8. Weber State
12. Nicholls
14. Montana State
15. Illinois State
16. Indiana State
17. Southeast Missouri
18. Northern Iowa
23. Sam Houston State

[GannonFan]

CSS, some people have a tough time understanding how geography effects polls, national awards, the need to schedule DII’s and multiple FBS games, etc. EG: 70% of your sports writers and coaches/SID’s who vote in the polls couldn’t find Pokafellow on a map.

Consider this a refresher.

Not sure I understand your point

Payton Award Winners
2017 Jeremiah Briscoe Sam Houston State
2016 Jeremiah Briscoe Sam Houston State
2015 Cooper Kupp Eastern Washington
2013 Jimmy Garoppolo Eastern Illinois
2011 Bo Levi Mitchell Eastern Washington
2010 Jeremy Moses Stephen F. Austin

Buchanan Award Winners
2018 Zach Hall Southeast Missouri State
2016 Karter Schult Northern Iowa
2014 Kyle Emanuel North Dakota State
2013 Brad Daly Montana State
2012 Caleb Schreibeis Montana State
2010 J. C. Sherritt Eastern Washington

Pre-Season I-AA Poll
1. North Dakota State
3. South Dakota State
4. Eastern Washington
5. UC Davis
8. Weber State
12. Nicholls
14. Montana State
15. Illinois State
16. Indiana State
17. Southeast Missouri
18. Northern Iowa
23. Sam Houston State

Notwithstanding 89's thorough smackdown of kalmie's unsubstantiated west coast whining, who really cares from an FCS standpoint? We have a large playoff system that any team remotely deserving (and many undeserving) get to make, so it's all decided on the field anyway. Those NDSU folks almost never moan about EC(b), so methinks the issue is more restricted to fanbases that need to use field color as a schtick than anything else.

[dbackjon]

CSS, some people have a tough time understanding how geography effects polls, national awards, the need to schedule DII’s and multiple FBS games, etc. EG: 70% of your sports writers and coaches/SID’s who vote in the polls couldn’t find Pokafellow on a map.

Consider this a refresher.

Not sure I understand your point

Payton Award Winners
2017 Jeremiah Briscoe Sam Houston State
2016 Jeremiah Briscoe Sam Houston State
2015 Cooper Kupp Eastern Washington
2013 Jimmy Garoppolo Eastern Illinois
2011 Bo Levi Mitchell Eastern Washington
2010 Jeremy Moses Stephen F. Austin

Buchanan Award Winners
2018 Zach Hall Southeast Missouri State
2016 Karter Schult Northern Iowa
2014 Kyle Emanuel North Dakota State
2013 Brad Daly Montana State
2012 Caleb Schreibeis Montana State
2010 J. C. Sherritt Eastern Washington

Pre-Season I-AA Poll
1. North Dakota State
3. South Dakota State
4. Eastern Washington
5. UC Davis
8. Weber State
12. Nicholls
14. Montana State
15. Illinois State
16. Indiana State
17. Southeast Missouri
18. Northern Iowa
23. Sam Houston State

The bolded are NOT west of the Mississippi.

The Underlined are on the Mississippi, not really western schools (Neither are NDSU or UNI).

[89Hen]

The bolded are NOT west of the Mississippi.

The Underlined are on the Mississippi, not really western schools (Neither are NDSU or UNI).

[kalm]

Not sure I understand your point

Payton Award Winners
2017 Jeremiah Briscoe Sam Houston State
2016 Jeremiah Briscoe Sam Houston State
2015 Cooper Kupp Eastern Washington
2013 Jimmy Garoppolo Eastern Illinois
2011 Bo Levi Mitchell Eastern Washington
2010 Jeremy Moses Stephen F. Austin

Buchanan Award Winners
2018 Zach Hall Southeast Missouri State
2016 Karter Schult Northern Iowa
2014 Kyle Emanuel North Dakota State
2013 Brad Daly Montana State
2012 Caleb Schreibeis Montana State
2010 J. C. Sherritt Eastern Washington

Pre-Season I-AA Poll
1. North Dakota State
3. South Dakota State
4. Eastern Washington
5. UC Davis
8. Weber State
12. Nicholls
14. Montana State
15. Illinois State
16. Indiana State
17. Southeast Missouri
18. Northern Iowa
23. Sam Houston State

The bolded are NOT west of the Mississippi.

The Underlined are on the Mississippi, not really western schools (Neither are NDSU or UNI).

Geography hard!

[89Hen]

Geography hard!

Sorry you failed so hard.

[dbackjon]

The bolded are NOT west of the Mississippi.

The Underlined are on the Mississippi, not really western schools (Neither are NDSU or UNI).

So you admit that you don't know Geography.

[89Hen]

So you admit that you don't know Geography.

What is the title of this thread? Exactly none of the ones you pointed out are east coast. EVEN dismissing the couple, it's clear that schools west of the Mississippi are OVER-represented in the awards and polls.

[dbackjon]

So you admit that you don't know Geography.

What is the title of this thread? Exactly none of the ones you pointed out are east coast. EVEN dismissing the couple, it's clear that schools west of the Mississippi are OVER-represented in the awards and polls.

The article used the Mississippi as the dividing line. Then YOU used schools EAST of the Mississippi to try to prove some point.

Just admit, you tried to sneak some flyover schools on the list to make it seem more impressive.

[89Hen]

What is the title of this thread? Exactly none of the ones you pointed out are east coast. EVEN dismissing the couple, it's clear that schools west of the Mississippi are OVER-represented in the awards and polls.

The article used the Mississippi as the dividing line. Then YOU used schools EAST of the Mississippi to try to prove some point.

Just admit, you tried to sneak some flyover schools on the list to make it seem more impressive.

It's plenty impressive without them, but I didn't read the article, just that Kalm, the creator of this thread, said it was east cost and it was Kalm who implied that somehow the awards and polls were biased against western schools.

[dbackjon]

The article used the Mississippi as the dividing line. Then YOU used schools EAST of the Mississippi to try to prove some point.

Just admit, you tried to sneak some flyover schools on the list to make it seem more impressive.

It's plenty impressive without them, but I didn't read the article, just that Kalm, the creator of this thread, said it was east cost and it was Kalm who implied that somehow the awards and polls were biased against western schools.

So you commented without knowledge. Got it.

[kalm]

Not sure I understand your point

Payton Award Winners
2017 Jeremiah Briscoe Sam Houston State
2016 Jeremiah Briscoe Sam Houston State
2015 Cooper Kupp Eastern Washington
2013 Jimmy Garoppolo Eastern Illinois
2011 Bo Levi Mitchell Eastern Washington
2010 Jeremy Moses Stephen F. Austin

Buchanan Award Winners
2018 Zach Hall Southeast Missouri State
2016 Karter Schult Northern Iowa
2014 Kyle Emanuel North Dakota State
2013 Brad Daly Montana State
2012 Caleb Schreibeis Montana State
2010 J. C. Sherritt Eastern Washington

Pre-Season I-AA Poll
1. North Dakota State
3. South Dakota State
4. Eastern Washington
5. UC Davis
8. Weber State
12. Nicholls
14. Montana State
15. Illinois State
16. Indiana State
17. Southeast Missouri
18. Northern Iowa
23. Sam Houston State

Notwithstanding 89's thorough smackdown of kalmie's unsubstantiated west coast whining, who really cares from an FCS standpoint? We have a large playoff system that any team remotely deserving (and many undeserving) get to make, so it's all decided on the field anyway. Those NDSU folks almost never moan about EC(b), so methinks the issue is more restricted to fanbases that need to use field color as a schtick than anything else.

You mean all three NDSU fans on this board don't moan about it???

Oh wait...Gil has mentioned it a number of times. So 2 out 3 haven't. Wow!

If you visited AGS you'd see it mentioned quite a bit.

89's weak rebuttal didn't prove shit other than the success witnessed by Western teams despite the obvious EC(b). And Dback is right, strip away the midwest teams and the point is even more pronounced.

[89Hen]

despite the obvious EC(b). And Dback is right, strip away the midwest teams and the point is even more pronounced.

So much fail.