I guess my gut favors Sam Houston State but I think only one of those home playoff wins by Sam Houston State was against Missouri Valley or prior to that Gateway teams. That was Western Kentucky of the Gateway in 2004. I don't know what any of the lines are but usually the lines are similar to power ratings margins. South Dakota is rated higher in power ratings than Sam Houston State is. They're a 7.58 point favorite in this game in spite of Sam Houston State being at home by Sagarin and a 6.75 point favorite by Massey. If you go by the rankings composite at
https://www.masseyratings.com/cf/compare1aa.htm South Dakota is at 11 while Sam Houston State is at 14.
It's an interesting thing because we're talking about the road team being from a much tougher conference and having played a much tougher schedule. If you go by the Sagarin schedule strength ratings South Dakota's slate is 130th among Division I schools while Sam Houston State's is 216th.
One thing's for sure: South Dakota isn't going to start off in awe of Sam Houston State. They've played several teams this year that are better than Sam Houston State and they know it. They know that in the Missouri Valley Sam Houston State would be a middle of the pack team. And since I said that I'll say that by the Sagarin Ratings Sam Houston State is rated lower than 7 of the 10 Missouri Valley Conference teams. Same with Massey. Seven Missouri Valley Conference teams are rated higher than Sam Houston State.
Sam Houston State was a lot more impressive than South Dakota was against their one common opponent; Nicholls State. But the Bearkats also struggled with 4-7 Stephen F. Austin, 4-7 Northwestern State, and 2-9 Abilene Christian.
Should be interesting. I would not be surprised to see either team blow the other one out. Would not be surprised to see either team win a close one. Nothing would surprise me with respect to this game.