GannonFan wrote:bluehenbillk wrote:Where is all the App chirp coming from? They got smacked, at home, by Villanova. Seriously, their defense got pushed all over the place & they couldn't cover either. You don't lose at home by 17 points by accident or by having a bad day, especially in December.
This tune has already been played - EWU is the only team that matters for UD fans, next.
Besides, who would've taken the bet that of the two teams that played for the title in '07, that it would be UD, and not Appy St, who would make it back to the title game sooner? Armanti still had two years left and despite that, UD has made it back to the title game before Appy St. You kow that's just gnawing at them at some level. Poor guys.

I know injuries are apart of the game and EWU can certainly make that claim losing what they have this year...but I would have loved to have replayed that 07 game with a healthy Marcorelle, Talley, and not had Uhll as a freshemn playing left tackle.
That being said...this thread is lame. You're talking right now about two teams that are at the tops of the FCS year in and year out... I will say this Appyholic...look back at the teams we used to play back in the day...they were no joke...if we are going by straight 1-AA standards for valid championship recognition, then can we really include those first few championships when 4 teams participated. Florida A&M...really?
I'd like to see a compiled list of all-stars, all-time squads from both teams...I'm willing to bet Appyholic and Gannonfan can come up with a SICK, SICK list...
DO IT!