CS Poll Week 10

[travelinman67]

Sorry about the delay...

1. North Dakota State Bison (300)
2. Eastern Illinois Panthers (280)
3. Eastern Washington Eagles (271)
4. Maine Black Bears (265)
5. Fordham Rams (254)
6. Coastal Carolina Chanticleers (234)
7. Montana State Bobcats (225)
8. Sam Houston State Bearkats (221)
9. Youngstown State Penguins (205)
10. Southeastern Louisiana Lions (180)
11. Northern Arizona Lumberjacks (172)
12. Towson Tigers (163)
13. Bethune-Cookman Wildcats (158)
14. McNeese Cowboys (148)
15. Montana Grizzlies (144)
16. Delaware Fightin’ Blue Hens (117)
17. Chattanooga Mocs (95)
18. Charleston Southern Buccaneers (88)
19. Samford Bulldogs (79)
20. William and Mary Tribe (69)
21. Wofford Terriers (62)
22. Southern Illinois Salukis (46)
23. James Madison Dukes (33)
24. Eastern Kentucky Colonels (21)
25. Jackson State Tigers (16)

Next 10 receiving votes:
26. Princeton Tigers (12), 27. Lehigh Mountain Hawks (10), 28. South Dakota State Jackrabbits (8), 29. Jacksonville State Gamecocks (8), 30. Tennessee State Tigers (4), 31. Central Arkansas Bears (3), 32. Southern Utah Thunderbirds (2), 33. Villanova Wildcats (1).

(only 8 teams beyond the top 25 receiving points)

[Ibanez]

Sorry about the delay...

1. North Dakota State Bison (300)
2. Eastern Illinois Panthers (280)
3. Eastern Washington Eagles (271)
4. Maine Black Bears (265)
5. Fordham Rams (254)
6. Coastal Carolina Chanticleers (234)
7. Montana State Bobcats (225)
8. Sam Houston State Bearkats (221)
9. Youngstown State Penguins (205)
10. Southeastern Louisiana Lions (180)
11. Northern Arizona Lumberjacks (172)
12. Towson Tigers (163)
13. Bethune-Cookman Wildcats (158)
14. McNeese Cowboys (148)
15. Montana Grizzlies (144)
16. Delaware Fightin’ Blue Hens (117)
17. Chattanooga Mocs (95)
18. Charleston Southern Buccaneers (88)
19. Samford Bulldogs (79)
20. William and Mary Tribe (69)
21. Wofford Terriers (62)
22. Southern Illinois Salukis (46)
23. James Madison Dukes (33)
24. Eastern Kentucky Colonels (21)
25. Jackson State Tigers (16)

Next 10 receiving votes:
26. Princeton Tigers (12), 27. Lehigh Mountain Hawks (10), 28. South Dakota State Jackrabbits (8), 29. Jacksonville State Gamecocks (8), 30. Tennessee State Tigers (4), 31. Central Arkansas Bears (3), 32. Southern Utah Thunderbirds (2), 33. Villanova Wildcats (1).

(only 8 teams beyond the top 25 receiving points)

I know CSU is 9-1, however they don't have a great SoS.

[dbackjon]

Fire Away! Looking at it, I made a couple of minor placement errors. Probably giving the SoCon too much credit.

#1 North Dakota State Bison
#2 Eastern Illinois Panthers
#3 Eastern Washington Eagles
#4 Maine Black Bears
#5 Fordham Rams
#6 Montana State Bobcats
#7 Sam Houston State Bearkats
#8 Northern Arizona Lumberjacks
#9 Coastal Carolina Chanticleers
#10 Youngstown State Penguins
#11 Towson Tigers
#12 Southeastern Louisiana Lions
#13 Montana Grizzlies
#14 McNeese State Cowboys
#15 Bethune-Cookman Wildcats
#16 Delaware Fightin' Blue Hens
#17 Southern Illinois Salukis
#18 William & Mary Tribe
#19 Charleston Southern Buccaneers
#20 Wofford Terriers
#21 Samford Bulldogs
#22 Chattanooga Mocs
#23 Princeton Tigers
#24 James Madison Dukes
#25 Jacksonville State Gamecocks

[89Hen]

4. Maine Black Bears (265)
7. Montana State Bobcats (225)

Somebody here got through to the voters.

[dbackjon]

4. Maine Black Bears (265)
7. Montana State Bobcats (225)

Somebody here got through to the voters.

I had Maine at 4, MSU at 6

Us gay fans have to stick together...




Wait, that doesn't sound quite right

[Gil Dobie]

4. Maine Black Bears (265)
7. Montana State Bobcats (225)

Somebody here got through to the voters.

Maine doesn't have the bad loss that Montana State does.

[YoUDeeMan]

#6 Montana State Bobcats

Somebody here doesn't watch much football and votes on only one issue.

Repeat after me...MSU has a DII win and LOST to a 3-6 team...a loss that was NOT an accident since they gave up 52 points and well over 500 yards to that 3-6 team.

Cripes, Fordham has a better resume than MSU.

[dbackjon]

#6 Montana State Bobcats

Somebody here doesn't watch much football and votes on only one issue.

Repeat after me...MSU has a DII win and LOST to a 3-6 team...a loss that was NOT an accident since they gave up 52 points and well over 500 yards to that 3-6 team.

Cripes, Fordham has a better resume than MSU.

I voted Fordham #5.

[Gil Dobie]

Somebody here got through to the voters.

I had Maine at 4, MSU at 6

Us gay fans have to stick together...




Wait, that doesn't sound quite right

Noticed UNH has dropped in the polls since Travis has been MIA.

[AZGrizFan]

Somebody here got through to the voters.

I had Maine at 4, MSU at 6

Us gay fans have to stick together...

Wait, that doesn't sound quite right

Well, most people don't think it sounds right, but apparently it's becoming more acceptable.

And I fucking forgot to vote this week.

[MrTitleist]

I'm not much diff than Jon.. a couple differences.

1. North Dakota State
2. Eastern Washington
3. Eastern Illinois
4. Montana State
5. Coastal Carolina
6. Fordham
7. Sam Houston State
8. Maine
9. Youngstown State
10. Towson
11. Southeastern Louisiana
12. Bethune Cookman
13. Montana
14. McNeese State
15. Chattanooga
16. Northern Arizona
17. Wofford
18. Samford
19. Delaware
20. James Madison
21. Charleston Southern
22. Lehigh
23. William and Mary
24. Priceton
25. Southern Utah

[kalm]

#6 Montana State Bobcats

Somebody here doesn't watch much football and votes on only one issue.

Repeat after me...MSU has a DII win and LOST to a 3-6 team...a loss that was NOT an accident since they gave up 52 points and well over 500 yards to that 3-6 team.

Cripes, Fordham has a better resume than MSU.

At the risk of starting this up again ...the D2 is probably equal to the Bryant and Norfolk State wins.

[dbackjon]

Mr T - care to explain how you have Montana 3 spots ahead of NAU?

[kalm]

Mr T - care to explain how you have Montana 3 spots ahead of NAU?

Jack Nazi...

[MrTitleist]

Mr T - care to explain how you have Montana 3 spots ahead of NAU?

Nope!

[dbackjon]

Mr T - care to explain how you have Montana 3 spots ahead of NAU?

Nope!

That is what I thought..

[MrTitleist]

I could explain it, but you won't care until I have the two schools reversed, so it really doesn't matter.

[Gil Dobie]

I could explain it, but you won't care until I have the two schools reversed, so it really doesn't matter.

[dbackjon]

I could explain it, but you won't care until I have the two schools reversed, so it really doesn't matter.

So in other words, no reason, just a homer vote. Got it - another delusional Montana fan that is clueless about football.

[MrTitleist]

I could explain it, but you won't care until I have the two schools reversed, so it really doesn't matter.

So in other words, no reason, just a homer vote. Got it - another delusional Montana fan that is clueless about football.

Here's the tl;dr version: The way I do my polls it's much harder for teams to move up than move down, and when NAU beat UM the two were very far a part in the polls. NAU may not have even been in my poll at that point.

[dbackjon]

So in other words, no reason, just a homer vote. Got it - another delusional Montana fan that is clueless about football.

Here's the tl;dr version: The way I do my polls it's much harder for teams to move up than move down, and when NAU beat UM the two were very far a part in the polls. NAU may not have even been in my poll at that point.

So you are so married to your pre-season poll you ignore the real world. Got it.

[MrTitleist]

My preseason poll looks nothing like this one. Luckily we all have the freedom to build our polls differently. See, I told you there'd be no point in explaining.

[grizzaholic]

My preseason poll looks nothing like this one. Luckily we all have the freedom to build our polls differently. See, I told you there'd be no point in explaining.

He just isn't tolerant of others thoughts.



And dback..I have been saying for a couple weeks now that Montana is still too high.

[AZGrizFan]

So in other words, no reason, just a homer vote. Got it - another delusional Montana fan that is clueless about football.

Here's the tl;dr version: The way I do my polls it's much harder for teams to move up than move down, and when NAU beat UM the two were very far a part in the polls. NAU may not have even been in my poll at that point.

What I have a problem with is putting undefeated or one-loss teams from historically weak conferences (I'm looking at you, Charleston Southern and Bethune Cookman) so high in the polls...these teams will historically be one-and-done in the tournament, taking a spot from a more deserving team that lost 3-4 games playing a schedule that is significantly more difficult.

[MrTitleist]

Do you consider EIU one of those, being from a historically weak conference? I have a hard time ranking Ivy's very high for the same reason.