Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Football Championship Subdivision discussions
clenz
Moderator Team
Moderator Team
Posts: 21211
Joined: Mon Jan 19, 2009 4:30 pm

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by clenz »

CoachL wrote:
clenz wrote:Du-freaking-quesne
Yeah, baby!

Du-freaking-quesne!!!

:rockon:

By the way, clenz, it is my understanding that Butler had come to an agreement to play at Northern Iowa but UNI backed out for some reason. Do you know why UNI cancelled the deal? :-?
I had never heard of such arrangement...Maybe Butler trick UNI into thinking it was a basketball game, then switched the wording to football at the last second and UNI picked up on it... :rofl:


Seriously though, I have no idea. I hadn't heard of such arrangments. I know we have had offers for a second FBS game that we have turned down (Michigan last season, thus why they played Delaware State), but Butler I hadn't heard. Not to say it didn't happen. If it did happen I would bet it is due to the SFA deal we came to with them. I don't know if it is a H-H with SFA or a 2-1 with 2 @ UNI and 1 @ SFA.
User avatar
pantherrob82
Level2
Level2
Posts: 2179
Joined: Mon Oct 22, 2007 11:47 pm
I am a fan of: UNI, Montana, UNH, McNees
Location: Davenport,IA

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by pantherrob82 »

CoachL wrote:
clenz wrote:Du-freaking-quesne
Yeah, baby!

Du-freaking-quesne!!!

:rockon:

By the way, clenz, it is my understanding that Butler had come to an agreement to play at Northern Iowa but UNI backed out for some reason. Do you know why UNI cancelled the deal? :-?
I've heard we tried Dayton, but never Butler. Only reason we would back out is because of a timing issue.
User avatar
CoachL
Level2
Level2
Posts: 1365
Joined: Wed Jan 20, 2010 6:13 pm
I am a fan of: Butler, Duquesne
Location: Central Coast of California

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by CoachL »

I heard about this agreement a couple years ago.

I don't remember the details. I seem to recall that the game was going to be this year or next. I do remember being rather disappointed that the game fell through, even though it was clear that Butler would take a lickin'. I was hoping that it would replace the Albion :roll: game.
blukeys
Level1
Level1
Posts: 102
Joined: Sun Jun 07, 2009 11:59 am
I am a fan of: Delaware
A.K.A.: blukeys

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by blukeys »

Franks Tanks wrote:
Dane96 wrote:
Again...who the "F" refuses to play them.

No...I am not letting Dayton off the hook; Dayton pulled the same bullshit with Albany years ago. It's either only home for them...or a home and home.

Life isn't fair...and teams in the NEC, Coastal when they were Indy, Jacksonville this year, etc. have had to suck it up and play on the road to get games.

You just go out and do it and STFU and allow the results to speak for themselves. Years ago you would hear the "old guard" teams moan and groan about having Albany, CCSU, etc come to their place...as it was a "pushover" game. Though we are having a down year this year, I am sure if you surveyed the fans, coaches and players of the teams we played they would say something like, "that's no pushover game...they may be less talented but they come to play."

Why? Because we went out on the road and became battle tested. You ask me-- it has been nothing short of a 100% success playing teams anywhere anytime. It worked for Gonzaga in hoops...Fresno and Boise in football...etc.

Dayton needs to stop scheduling Central State and Urbana...and get on it and schedule anyone at any field. You build national respect by doing so, irrespective of whether it's fair.
Dayton doesn't really want to play the big boys so they throw out a ridicilious home and home offer. They know damm well App State or Northern Iowa will not do a home and home and they won't have to play them. Dayton can then go around crying that they can't get the games etc.

Lafayette is playing NDSU next year in a one year deal at the Fargodome. Lafayette almost always gets home and homes, but we decided it was worth no return trip to play the Bison. Dayton needs to do the same thing if they want to be taken seriously.
Franks Tanks and Dane 96 :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb:

The Dayton group is the whiniest of crybabies I have ever seen. Does the bogus UD really think they are getting a H-H with the real UD?

The Dayton crowd always whines that the big boys won't play them. They never produce any facts of how they contacted another school, what where the terms nor what were the responses. In short they produce for facts bupkis!!! :thumbdown:

This is so reminiscent of 3 years ago, that I am convinced that the whole San Diego, Harbaugh, Josh Johnson contingent has moved east.
DetroitFlyer
Level1
Level1
Posts: 144
Joined: Mon Jul 16, 2007 8:09 am
I am a fan of: University of Dayton

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by DetroitFlyer »

blukeys wrote:
Franks Tanks wrote:
Dayton doesn't really want to play the big boys so they throw out a ridicilious home and home offer. They know damm well App State or Northern Iowa will not do a home and home and they won't have to play them. Dayton can then go around crying that they can't get the games etc.

Lafayette is playing NDSU next year in a one year deal at the Fargodome. Lafayette almost always gets home and homes, but we decided it was worth no return trip to play the Bison. Dayton needs to do the same thing if they want to be taken seriously.
Franks Tanks and Dane 96 :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb:

The Dayton group is the whiniest of crybabies I have ever seen. Does the bogus UD really think they are getting a H-H with the real UD?

The Dayton crowd always whines that the big boys won't play them. They never produce any facts of how they contacted another school, what where the terms nor what were the responses. In short they produce for facts bupkis!!! :thumbdown:

This is so reminiscent of 3 years ago, that I am convinced that the whole San Diego, Harbaugh, Josh Johnson contingent has moved east.
I challenge you right now to find a post where this Dayton fan, one DetroitFlyer, has ever whined that the big boys will not play us.... Dayton has historically been interested in home/home arrangements. We gave Fordham a 2/1, but after we beat them twice they backed out of the third game.... NO TEAM in FCS is too good for a home/home with the Flyers. Some of you seem to think that you are The Ohio State University for crying out loud.... Trust me, no one outside of the cornfields and ethanol plants of Iowa know who the heck UNI is.... Dayton does football right. We win games and conference titles, we have extremely high academic achievements by our players, we actually graduate players, and we do it all with a non-athletic scholarship model. Look, I get it, NO ONE is going to attend UNI to play football without an athletic scholarship. Players WANT to attend Dayton. Just like players want to attend the Ivy League schools, PL schools, etc. We can and do get FCS athletic scholarship type players because of who we are and our program. This fact is true of most of the PFL schools. As I've stated previously, Dayton WILL be playing a traditional FCS program in each of the next two seasons.... I do not know if the games are home/home, but it will happen. Let's just say that I am really looking forward to winning the game in 2012!
clenz
Moderator Team
Moderator Team
Posts: 21211
Joined: Mon Jan 19, 2009 4:30 pm

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by clenz »

DetroitFlyer wrote:
blukeys wrote:
Franks Tanks and Dane 96 :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb: :thumb:

The Dayton group is the whiniest of crybabies I have ever seen. Does the bogus UD really think they are getting a H-H with the real UD?

The Dayton crowd always whines that the big boys won't play them. They never produce any facts of how they contacted another school, what where the terms nor what were the responses. In short they produce for facts bupkis!!! :thumbdown:

This is so reminiscent of 3 years ago, that I am convinced that the whole San Diego, Harbaugh, Josh Johnson contingent has moved east.
I challenge you right now to find a post where this Dayton fan, one DetroitFlyer, has ever whined that the big boys will not play us.... Dayton has historically been interested in home/home arrangements. We gave Fordham a 2/1, but after we beat them twice they backed out of the third game.... NO TEAM in FCS is too good for a home/home with the Flyers. Some of you seem to think that you are The Ohio State University for crying out loud.... Trust me, no one outside of the cornfields and ethanol plants of Iowa know who the heck UNI is.... Dayton does football right. We win games and conference titles, we have extremely high academic achievements by our players, we actually graduate players, and we do it all with a non-athletic scholarship model. Look, I get it, NO ONE is going to attend UNI to play football without an athletic scholarship. Players WANT to attend Dayton. Just like players want to attend the Ivy League schools, PL schools, etc. We can and do get FCS athletic scholarship type players because of who we are and our program. This fact is true of most of the PFL schools. As I've stated previously, Dayton WILL be playing a traditional FCS program in each of the next two seasons.... I do not know if the games are home/home, but it will happen. Let's just say that I am really looking forward to winning the game in 2012!
Um...where do I start

You won't get a straight home and home with anyone in the CAA, MVFC, SoCon, etc... Drake doesn't even get a straight home and home from UNI.

People know who UNI is. We made this thing called the Sweet 16 last year and beat the #1 team in the nation...I'd go further into detail, but let's put it this way....."People know us".

A lot of our players don't get scholarship. Mark Farley is known as the Walk-on from Waukon. The best QB in UNI history started as a walk on, Kurt Warner didn't have a scholarship the entire time he was here.

UNI had a linebacker the last 4 years that carried a 4.0 in a double major, graduated in three years, then pulled a 4.0 while getting his masters and playing his senior season. He won something like $50K in post graduate scholarships for his academics. UNI's best d-lineman right now is carrying a 3.85 GPA. I can go on and on and on and on if you like.

Drake doesn't get shit for players, period. To say that PFL teams get the same talent as the CAA, SoCon, Big Sky, MVFC, etc... is funny. The people that play at those schools weren't good enough to get a walk on spot at the other schools and went to where they could go to school and play, nothing wrong with that.
User avatar
jd of de
Level1
Level1
Posts: 424
Joined: Wed Dec 09, 2009 6:23 pm
I am a fan of: Delaware & Illinois

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by jd of de »

DetroitFlyer wrote:
blukeys wrote:
Image
NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIPS 1946 · 1963 · 1971 · 1972 · 1979 · 2003
RUNNERS-UP · 1974 · 1978 · 1982 · 2007 · 2010
Image
5 time Division 1-A National Champions & 5 - Final Fours
User avatar
jd of de
Level1
Level1
Posts: 424
Joined: Wed Dec 09, 2009 6:23 pm
I am a fan of: Delaware & Illinois

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by jd of de »

"NO TEAM in FCS is too good for a home/home with the Flyers."

Want Delaware on a home and home? Then pay up because your 3,900 fan gate isn't a $$$ match to our 20,000+ gate. Don't they teach math at Dayton?
Image
NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIPS 1946 · 1963 · 1971 · 1972 · 1979 · 2003
RUNNERS-UP · 1974 · 1978 · 1982 · 2007 · 2010
Image
5 time Division 1-A National Champions & 5 - Final Fours
Ursus A. Horribilis
Maroon Supporter
Maroon Supporter
Posts: 21615
Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 12:17 pm
I am a fan of: Montana Grizzlies
A.K.A.: Bill Brasky

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by Ursus A. Horribilis »

jd of de wrote:"NO TEAM in FCS is too good for a home/home with the Flyers."

Want Delaware on a home and home? Then pay up because your 3,900 fan gate isn't a $$$ match to our 20,000+ gate. Don't they teach math at Dayton?
He is having trouble with the concept jd, I tried explaining that and somehow he took it to mean that the teams that have a big gate see themselves as Ohio State. :lol:

You can not make it financially worth it for a team to give up a home game to visit you. In fact if 3900 fans is all that go to your games then you'd be money ahead to take the single away games at places like UD, App, & MT and then you could say you got the dog fuck kicked out of you in front of a lot of people all around the country. :thumb:
clenz
Moderator Team
Moderator Team
Posts: 21211
Joined: Mon Jan 19, 2009 4:30 pm

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by clenz »

Ursus A. Horribilis wrote:
jd of de wrote:"NO TEAM in FCS is too good for a home/home with the Flyers."

Want Delaware on a home and home? Then pay up because your 3,900 fan gate isn't a $$$ match to our 20,000+ gate. Don't they teach math at Dayton?
He is having trouble with the concept jd, I tried explaining that and somehow he took it to mean that the teams that have a big gate see themselves as Ohio State. :lol:

You can not make it financially worth it for a team to give up a home game to visit you. In fact if 3900 fans is all that go to your games then you'd be money ahead to take the single away games at places like UD, App, & MT and then you could say you got the dog fuck kicked out of you in front of a lot of people all around the country. :thumb:
Yep.

Dayton's tickets cost 10 each for an adult and 5 for youth.

Now, let's say that the players fill their allotment of comp tickets. That is about 400 tickets (I believe each player gets 4 tickets for home games and 2 for road games). That means there are 3500 tickets to be sold. It appears Dayton charges students $5 to get in. Finally Dayton charges 60 for a season ticket (so with 6 home games whats the point of the season ticket compared to individual games? I digress)

So, out of those 3500 left to sell I'll guess that about 1K of them fall under the $5 ticket range (Youth tickets (college, with ID, and younger)). So, that is $5,000.

That means that 2,500 tickets were sold at $10 a piece...or $25,000.


All that added together means Dayton brings in a total of $30,000 per game, before expenses have to be paid.

UNI paid St. Francis about 50k, plus travel, to come to the dome in 2009. You are up at least 20K there compared to a home game. St. Francis probably could have gotten more but they needed the game more than UNI did and they knew they weren't getting UNI out there.


On the flip side teams like UD, Montana, UNI, NDSU, etc... are pulling in a whole lot more in one home game than you make in a seasons worth of home games
Ursus A. Horribilis
Maroon Supporter
Maroon Supporter
Posts: 21615
Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 12:17 pm
I am a fan of: Montana Grizzlies
A.K.A.: Bill Brasky

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by Ursus A. Horribilis »

clenz wrote:
Ursus A. Horribilis wrote: He is having trouble with the concept jd, I tried explaining that and somehow he took it to mean that the teams that have a big gate see themselves as Ohio State. :lol:

You can not make it financially worth it for a team to give up a home game to visit you. In fact if 3900 fans is all that go to your games then you'd be money ahead to take the single away games at places like UD, App, & MT and then you could say you got the dog fuck kicked out of you in front of a lot of people all around the country. :thumb:
Yep.

Dayton's tickets cost 10 each for an adult and 5 for youth.

Now, let's say that the players fill their allotment of comp tickets. That is about 400 tickets (I believe each player gets 4 tickets for home games and 2 for road games). That means there are 3500 tickets to be sold. It appears Dayton charges students $5 to get in. Finally Dayton charges 60 for a season ticket (so with 6 home games whats the point of the season ticket compared to individual games? I digress)

So, out of those 3500 left to sell I'll guess that about 1K of them fall under the $5 ticket range (Youth tickets (college, with ID, and younger)). So, that is $5,000.

That means that 2,500 tickets were sold at $10 a piece...or $25,000.


All that added together means Dayton brings in a total of $30,000 per game, before expenses have to be paid.

UNI paid St. Francis about 50k, plus travel, to come to the dome in 2009. You are up at least 20K there compared to a home game. St. Francis probably could have gotten more but they needed the game more than UNI did and they knew they weren't getting UNI out there.


On the flip side teams like UD, Montana, UNI, NDSU, etc... are pulling in a whole lot more in one home game than you make in a seasons worth of home games
I know UM paid at least that for Western State and UM clears over 1/2 million on those games.

So Dayton...you ain't getting a fucking H&H. Now you know why. There are a lot of teams out there that were in that position before like the previously mentioned Albany, and even Cal Poly 10 yrs. ago. Cal Poly made the moves they had to and gained a shit load of respect around the country and now are not scheduling like the Dayton's of the world and are a highly respected team along with Albany and many others. The road ain't a secret fella's.
clenz
Moderator Team
Moderator Team
Posts: 21211
Joined: Mon Jan 19, 2009 4:30 pm

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by clenz »

Ursus A. Horribilis wrote:
clenz wrote: Yep.

Dayton's tickets cost 10 each for an adult and 5 for youth.

Now, let's say that the players fill their allotment of comp tickets. That is about 400 tickets (I believe each player gets 4 tickets for home games and 2 for road games). That means there are 3500 tickets to be sold. It appears Dayton charges students $5 to get in. Finally Dayton charges 60 for a season ticket (so with 6 home games whats the point of the season ticket compared to individual games? I digress)

So, out of those 3500 left to sell I'll guess that about 1K of them fall under the $5 ticket range (Youth tickets (college, with ID, and younger)). So, that is $5,000.

That means that 2,500 tickets were sold at $10 a piece...or $25,000.


All that added together means Dayton brings in a total of $30,000 per game, before expenses have to be paid.

UNI paid St. Francis about 50k, plus travel, to come to the dome in 2009. You are up at least 20K there compared to a home game. St. Francis probably could have gotten more but they needed the game more than UNI did and they knew they weren't getting UNI out there.


On the flip side teams like UD, Montana, UNI, NDSU, etc... are pulling in a whole lot more in one home game than you make in a seasons worth of home games
I know UM paid at least that for Western State and UM clears over 1/2 million on those games.

So Dayton...you ain't getting a fucking H&H. Now you know why. There are a lot of teams out there that were in that position before like the previously mentioned Albany, and even Cal Poly 10 yrs. ago. Cal Poly made the moves they had to and gained a shit load of respect around the country and now are not scheduling like the Dayton's of the world and are a highly respected team along with Albany and many others. The road ain't a secret fella's.
If my math is correct UNI clears about 230K per home game...ish.

If Dayton can basically pay UNI 250K for their part of the H-H then it might work
User avatar
FargoBison
Level2
Level2
Posts: 1058
Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2007 3:44 pm
I am a fan of: NDSU

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by FargoBison »

Seriously Dayton come to Fargo, we'll give you $100-150K and you can have a chance to prove your worth.
DetroitFlyer
Level1
Level1
Posts: 144
Joined: Mon Jul 16, 2007 8:09 am
I am a fan of: University of Dayton

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by DetroitFlyer »

clenz wrote:
Ursus A. Horribilis wrote: I know UM paid at least that for Western State and UM clears over 1/2 million on those games.

So Dayton...you ain't getting a **** H&H. Now you know why. There are a lot of teams out there that were in that position before like the previously mentioned Albany, and even Cal Poly 10 yrs. ago. Cal Poly made the moves they had to and gained a **** load of respect around the country and now are not scheduling like the Dayton's of the world and are a highly respected team along with Albany and many others. The road ain't a secret fella's.
If my math is correct UNI clears about 230K per home game...ish.

If Dayton can basically pay UNI 250K for their part of the H-H then it might work
Nope. If you want to play the mighty Flyers, there is no money. Man up and come down to Welcome Stadium and get you butts kicked.... Not really all that complicated. People know who UNI is.... Give me a break....
clenz
Moderator Team
Moderator Team
Posts: 21211
Joined: Mon Jan 19, 2009 4:30 pm

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by clenz »

DetroitFlyer wrote:
clenz wrote: If my math is correct UNI clears about 230K per home game...ish.

If Dayton can basically pay UNI 250K for their part of the H-H then it might work
Nope. If you want to play the mighty Flyers, there is no money. Man up and come down to Welcome Stadium and get you butts kicked.... Not really all that complicated. People know who UNI is.... Give me a break....
Dayton is known for hosting the PIG of the NCAA tournament....That's something to hang your hat on.


The fact is college athletics is a business. You want us to come to Dayton? Head on up to Cedar Falls two a three times. You know, man up and get your butts kicked.

Get our butts kicked, please. I think Superhornet has a higher IQ than you.
Ursus A. Horribilis
Maroon Supporter
Maroon Supporter
Posts: 21615
Joined: Sun Oct 07, 2007 12:17 pm
I am a fan of: Montana Grizzlies
A.K.A.: Bill Brasky

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by Ursus A. Horribilis »

DetroitFlyer wrote:
clenz wrote: If my math is correct UNI clears about 230K per home game...ish.

If Dayton can basically pay UNI 250K for their part of the H-H then it might work
Nope. If you want to play the mighty Flyers, there is no money. Man up and come down to Welcome Stadium and get you butts kicked.... Not really all that complicated. People know who UNI is.... Give me a break....
It doesn't appear that you guys could even cover travel. :lol:

The teams you want to play or say you want to play don't need the respect because they would not garner any by beating you. Asking any athletic dpt. to give up 300-500K just isn't very logical is it? I'll have to assume that you must be extremely intelligent in all areas except simple math. :thumb:
YoUDeeMan
Level5
Level5
Posts: 12088
Joined: Mon Jul 16, 2007 8:48 am
I am a fan of: Fleecing the Stupid
A.K.A.: Delaware Homie

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by YoUDeeMan »

Ursus A. Horribilis wrote:
DetroitFlyer wrote:
Nope. If you want to play the mighty Flyers, there is no money. Man up and come down to Welcome Stadium and get you butts kicked.... Not really all that complicated. People know who UNI is.... Give me a break....
It doesn't appear that you guys could even cover travel. :lol:

The teams you want to play or say you want to play don't need the respect because they would not garner any by beating you. Asking any athletic dpt. to give up 300-500K just isn't very logical is it? I'll have to assume that you must be extremely intelligent in all areas except simple math. :thumb:
Dayton must specialize in left wing nut job learning. Money doesn't matter...it will fall from the sky if you need it. Tax other people's earnings and redistribute it to the poor people. Why do you good football teams always want to make money? :dunce:
These signatures have a 500 character limit?

What if I have more personalities than that?
User avatar
jd of de
Level1
Level1
Posts: 424
Joined: Wed Dec 09, 2009 6:23 pm
I am a fan of: Delaware & Illinois

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by jd of de »

DetroitFlyer wrote: Nope. If you want to play the mighty Flyers, there is no money. Man up and come down to Welcome Stadium and get you butts kicked.... Not really all that complicated. People know who UNI is.... Give me a break....
Man up?

Delaware 30 .... Duquesne 6
Dayton 31 ....... Duquesne 35

Get real Flyers.
Image
NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIPS 1946 · 1963 · 1971 · 1972 · 1979 · 2003
RUNNERS-UP · 1974 · 1978 · 1982 · 2007 · 2010
Image
5 time Division 1-A National Champions & 5 - Final Fours
User avatar
CoachL
Level2
Level2
Posts: 1365
Joined: Wed Jan 20, 2010 6:13 pm
I am a fan of: Butler, Duquesne
Location: Central Coast of California

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by CoachL »

clenz wrote:The people that play at those schools (PFL) weren't good enough to get a walk on spot at the other schools and went to where they could go to school and play, nothing wrong with that.
Okay, clenz...

I believe that you overstepped with this one, and I take personal offense at this statement.

My older son, a 2-Star high school recruit had FCS scholarship offers from NEC schools and walk-on offers from CAA schools. He chose Butler.

He chose Butler because he felt that it was the best school for him. (And BOY has it ever been!!)

Your statement was wrong, misinformed, and insulting to each and every player in the PFL. :ohno:

:thumbdown:
User avatar
89Hen
Supporter
Supporter
Posts: 39258
Joined: Tue Jul 17, 2007 1:13 pm
I am a fan of: High Horses
A.K.A.: The Almighty Arbiter

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by 89Hen »

Ursus A. Horribilis wrote:In fact if 3900 fans is all that go to your games then you'd be money ahead to take the single away games at places like UD, App, & MT and then you could say you got the dog fuck kicked out of you in front of a lot of people all around the country. :thumb:
:nod: :thumb:
Image
clenz
Moderator Team
Moderator Team
Posts: 21211
Joined: Mon Jan 19, 2009 4:30 pm

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by clenz »

CoachL wrote:
clenz wrote:The people that play at those schools (PFL) weren't good enough to get a walk on spot at the other schools and went to where they could go to school and play, nothing wrong with that.
Okay, clenz...

I believe that you overstepped with this one, and I take personal offense at this statement.

My older son, a 2-Star high school recruit had FCS scholarship offers from NEC schools and walk-on offers from CAA schools. He chose Butler.

He chose Butler because he felt that it was the best school for him. (And BOY has it ever been!!)

Your statement was wrong, misinformed, and insulting to each and every player in the PFL. :ohno:

:thumbdown:
So he had walk on offers from the CAA and offers from the NEC, who isn't much higher than the PFL

Are there guys on PFL teams that could play for CAA, MVFC, SoCon, and Big Sky teams? You bet. That doesn't mean those teams are as good.

It's like the top level of FCS teams. We all have players that could easily play B12, B10, PAC 10, BE, ACC, SEC football but they don't. Now, does that make the top level schools as good as the BCS schools?
User avatar
CoachL
Level2
Level2
Posts: 1365
Joined: Wed Jan 20, 2010 6:13 pm
I am a fan of: Butler, Duquesne
Location: Central Coast of California

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by CoachL »

clenz wrote:
CoachL wrote:
Okay, clenz...

I believe that you overstepped with this one, and I take personal offense at this statement.

My older son, a 2-Star high school recruit had FCS scholarship offers from NEC schools and walk-on offers from CAA schools. He chose Butler.

He chose Butler because he felt that it was the best school for him. (And BOY has it ever been!!)

Your statement was wrong, misinformed, and insulting to each and every player in the PFL. :ohno:

:thumbdown:
So he had walk on offers from the CAA and offers from the NEC, who isn't much higher than the PFL

Are there guys on PFL teams that could play for CAA, MVFC, SoCon, and Big Sky teams? You bet. That doesn't mean those teams are as good.

It's like the top level of FCS teams. We all have players that could easily play B12, B10, PAC 10, BE, ACC, SEC football but they don't. Now, does that make the top level schools as good as the BCS schools?
A.) Thank you for making my point! Please re-read your ignorant and unnecessarily insulting post. Your attack was not on PFL teams, it was on PFL players. :ohno:

B.) Sagarin Conference Rankings:

1 PAC-10 (A)
2 SOUTHEASTERN (A)
3 BIG 12 (A)
4 BIG TEN (A)
5 ATLANTIC COAST (A)
6 I-A INDEPENDENTS (A)
7 BIG EAST (A)
8 WESTERN ATHLETIC (A)
9 MOUNTAIN WEST (A)
10 CONFERENCE USA (A)
11 COLONIAL (AA)
12 BIG SKY (AA)
13 MID-AMERICAN (A)
14 SOUTHERN (AA)
15 MISSOURI VALLEY (AA)
16 GREAT WEST (AA)
17 SUN BELT (A)
18 SOUTHLAND (AA)
19 NORTHEAST (AA)
20 OHIO VALLEY (AA)
21 IVY LEAGUE (AA)
22 PATRIOT LEAGUE (AA)
23 I-AA INDEPENDENTS (AA)
24 BIG SOUTH (AA)
25 SOUTHWESTERN (AA)
26 PIONEER (AA)
27 MID-EASTERN (AA)
clenz
Moderator Team
Moderator Team
Posts: 21211
Joined: Mon Jan 19, 2009 4:30 pm

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by clenz »

I'm failing to see the problem to the extent you are.

The area *some* players at the NEC,PFL level that could play for the top 3 or 4 FCS conferences. Just like there are *some* players in the FCS that could play in the top 3 or 4 conferences of the FBS, and to a greater exntent the lower levels of the FBS.


I get it, your son had that offer and you think I'm attacking him. I'm not. I'm saying the difference in overall depth of talent between the NEC, PFL, SWAC, MEACN, Big South, OVC, etc... is significantly lower than it is in the CAA, Big Sky, MVFC, SoCon
User avatar
CoachL
Level2
Level2
Posts: 1365
Joined: Wed Jan 20, 2010 6:13 pm
I am a fan of: Butler, Duquesne
Location: Central Coast of California

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by CoachL »

clenz wrote:I'm failing to see the problem to the extent you are.

The area *some* players at the NEC,PFL level that could play for the top 3 or 4 FCS conferences. Just like there are *some* players in the FCS that could play in the top 3 or 4 conferences of the FBS, and to a greater exntent the lower levels of the FBS.

I get it, your son had that offer and you think I'm attacking him. I'm not. I'm saying the difference in overall depth of talent between the NEC, PFL, SWAC, MEACN, Big South, OVC, etc... is significantly lower than it is in the CAA, Big Sky, MVFC, SoCon
:roll:

This is what you originally wrote:

"The people that play at those schools weren't good enough to get a walk on spot at the other schools and went to where they could go to school and play, nothing wrong with that."

I know the difference in overall depth. I've been saying that exact thing on this board and on AGS for years. Your original post did not say that, however. Read it again...
clenz
Moderator Team
Moderator Team
Posts: 21211
Joined: Mon Jan 19, 2009 4:30 pm

Re: Congratulations to Dayton and Jacksonville

Post by clenz »

CoachL wrote:
clenz wrote:I'm failing to see the problem to the extent you are.

The area *some* players at the NEC,PFL level that could play for the top 3 or 4 FCS conferences. Just like there are *some* players in the FCS that could play in the top 3 or 4 conferences of the FBS, and to a greater exntent the lower levels of the FBS.

I get it, your son had that offer and you think I'm attacking him. I'm not. I'm saying the difference in overall depth of talent between the NEC, PFL, SWAC, MEACN, Big South, OVC, etc... is significantly lower than it is in the CAA, Big Sky, MVFC, SoCon
:roll:

This is what you originally wrote:

"The people that play at those schools weren't good enough to get a walk on spot at the other schools and went to where they could go to school and play, nothing wrong with that."

I know the difference in overall depth. I've been saying that exact thing on this board and on AGS for years. Your original post did not say that, however. Read it again...
Ok...I'll add three words and change another and my post will be correct and not single your son out. Man, there is nothing like a athletes parents when they feel their son/daughter got attacked.

"The greater majority of people that play at those schools weren't good enough to get a scholly spot at the other schools and went to where they could go to school and play, nothing wrong with that."
Post Reply