UMT 41-42 CP WEB 38-35 UCD
SAC 34-42 IDST
PORTST 31-45 SUU EWU 50-35 NAU UND 17-15 MTST
NConf Record: 0-0 Overall: 16-19
vs. FCS: 0-0 Overall: 9-4
Best Performance: (#4) Eastern Washington 50, Northern Arizona 35 - Gage Gubrud rebounds from his benching to amass 487 yards of total offense and 3 total touchdowns.
Worst Performance: Sacramento St. 34, Idaho St. 42 - The Hornets seem destined for the Big Sky basement after allowing Michael Dean to run for 154 yards on just 4 carries.
Most Surprising Result: Portland St. 31, Southern Utah 45 - Last year, through 4 games, the Vikings were allowing 12.5 ppg and 318 total ypg. This year, through 4 games, the Viks are giving up 44.5 ppg and 509 ypg.
Southland
SHSU 52-16 HBU
ACU 30-41 SFA UCA 28-23 ARST
NWST 24-34 SELU MCNSE 42-35 UIW
NICH 40-41 USA(OT)
NConf Record: 1-1 Overall: 5-13
vs. FCS: 0-0 Overall: 1-3
Best Performance: Central Arkansas 28, (FBS) Arkansas St. 23 - The Bears win turnovers 4-0 and outscore the Red Wolves 21-7 down the stretch to pick up their second-ever FBS victory.
Worst Performance: Northwestern St. 24, Southeastern Louisiana 34 - Demons start 0-4 for the second-straight year.
Most Surprising Result: Nicholls St. 40, (FBS) South Alabama 41 (OT) - Despite being dominated in yardage, the Colonels are just barely denied an FBS upset for the 2nd. time in 3 weeks.
Best Performance: (#13) Western Illinois 28, (FBS) Northern Illinois 23 - The Leathernecks build a 28-7 lead and just barely hold on as they knock off the de facto king of the directional Illinois schools.
Worst Performance: (#9) Illinois St. 31, Indiana St. 34 - The Redbirds are tackled for loss 10 times and have completely squandered any momentum that Northwestern win may have provided.
Most Surprising Result: Indiana St. 34, (#9) Illinois St. 31 - This is just ISU(b)'s 3rd. win over ISU(r) in the last 19 years.
Best Performance: (#3) Jacksonville St. 48, Liberty 19 - The Gamecocks end Liberty's 6-game home win streak in dominant fashion, outgaining them 563-181.
Worst Performance: Murray St. 16, Southeast Missouri St. 17 - Racers fall to 6-21 since the start of 2014.
Most Surprising Result: Austin Peay 35, (#18) Eastern Illinois 56 - This is sadly the most points the Governors have scored since the end of the 2012 season.
Pioneer League
DAY 22-34 USD
MHEAD 28-30 DRAKE
DVDSN 20-24 VALPO
BUT 27-33 CAMP(OT) JU 24-7 STET
NConf Record: 0-0 Overall: 14-16
vs. FCS: 0-0 Overall: 1-15
Best Performance: San Diego 34, Dayton 22 - Anthony Lawrence throws for 371 yards for the Toreros, nearly 150 yards more than the entire team output for Dayton.
Worst Performance: Davidson 20, Valparaiso 24 - When you've lost 3 straight to Valpo, that's not a sign you're heading in the right direction.
PRINCE 28-42 LEH NOVA 31-14 LAF VMI 23-17 BUCK (3OT)
COLG 31-38 RICH
PENN 17-31 FORD DART 35-10 HC
COLUM 14-17 GTOWN
NConf Record: 3-4 Overall: 11-14
vs. FCS: 3-4 Overall: 10-12
Best Performance: Fordham 31, Penn 17 - Chase Edmonds continues to do his thing as he puts up 201 total yards and 4 total touchdowns.
Worst Performance: Bucknell 17, VMI 23 (3OT) - It was a game nobody wanted to win as neither team scored any points in the first two overtimes and both teams combined for 5 turnovers and 5 missed field goals.
Most Surprising Result: Holy Cross 10, Dartmouth 35 - Not only did the Crusaders suffer a disappointing defeat, they also lost QB Peter Pujals to an ankle injury.
Best Performance: Sacred Heart 38, (#20) Stony Brook 10 - In their first meeting since SBU left the NEC 9 years ago, the Pioneers do to the Seawolves what the Seawolves did to Richmond a week ago.
Worst Performance: Robert Morrs 21, (DII) Malone 19 - Only 232 yards of offense for the Colonials as they nearly drop another non-DI game.
Most Surprising Result: Sacred Heart 38, (#20) Stony Brook 10 - Sacred Heart is suddenly a favorite to win their 3rd. NEC title in 4 years.
CAA
NOVA 31-14 LAF
SFPA 9-20 ALB SACHRT 38-10 SBU JMU 31-20 MAINE UNH 39-17 URI
COLG 31-38 RICH ELON 27-10 W&M
NConf Record: 3-1 Overall: 18-15
vs. FCS: 3-1 Overall: 15-4
Best Performance: Elon 27, (#8) William & Mary 10 - The Phoenix defense forces the Tribe into effectively 7 turnovers—3 INTs and 0/4 on fourth down.
Worst Performance: (#8) William & Mary 10, Elon 27 - 4 games into last season, Steve Cluley had only thrown 1 interception. So far this year, he's got 7.
Most Surprising Result: Elon 27, (#8) William & Mary 10 - 3 of Elon's 4 conference wins since joining the CAA have come on the road, oddly enough.
Best Performance: (#12) Charleston Southern 35, Monmouth 7 - It's been an odd stretch of adversity since nearly beating NDSU, but that didn't stop the Bucs from outrushing Monmouth 322-59.
Worst Performance: Presbyterian 7, (DII) Florida Tech 28 - Against a good DII, the Blue Hose score just 7 points in 5 redzone trips.
Most Surprising Result: Kennesaw St. 36, Duquesne 28 - The option-based Owls throw for 312 yards and take advantage of 4 Dillon Buechel interceptions (3 of them grabbed by Dante Blackmon).
SoCon
VMI 23-17 BUCK (3OT)
FUR 21-41 CCU
ETSU 0-31 WOFF
SAM 21-41 UTC
NConf Record: 1-1 Overall: 12-6
vs. FCS: 1-0 Overall: 9-0
Best Performance: (#5) Tennessee-Chattanooga 41, Samford 21 - Derrick Craine runs for 222 yards and 2 TDs in a strong Moc victory.
Worst Performance: East Tennessee St. 0, Wofford 31 - Back to Earth for the Buccaneers as they get outrushed 350 to minus-7.
Most Surprising Result: East Tennessee St. 0, Wofford 31 - This may seem like a bit of a setback for ETSU, but keep in mind that only 2 of their FCS losses last year were closer than this.
Tomorrow: Non-Playoff Folks…
Last edited by Mvemjsunpx on Tue Oct 04, 2016 2:38 am, edited 1 time in total.
PENN 17-31 FORD
COLUM 14-17 GTOWN
YALE 13-27 COR DART 35-10 HC HARV 32-22 BROWN
PRINCE 28-42 LEH
NConf Record: 1-3 Overall: 6-6
vs. FCS: 1-3 Overall: 6-6
Best Performance: Dartmouth 35. Holy Cross 10 - The Big Green force 4 turnovers and end the game on a 35-3 run.
Worst Performance: Yale 13, Cornell 27 - The Bulldogs have committed 4 turnovers in each of their first 2 games.
Most Surprising Result: Cornell 27, Yale 13 - Big Red start 2-0 for the first time since '09. They didn't end up winning another game then, however.
MEAC
DSU 0-79 MIZ
HOW 24-28 MORG NCCEN 34-31 NFOLK
BCU 10-16 SAV(OT) SCSU 48-14 FAMU
NConf Record: 0-1 Overall: 4-24
vs. FCS: 0-0 Overall: 0-8
Best Performance: Savannah St. 16, Bethune-Cookman 10 (OT) - Savannah State? Best!? Zzzuhh?
Worst Performance: Bethune-Cookman 10, Savannah St. 16 (OT) - The Wildcats score as many points in 4 redzone trips as the Tigers do in 1 trip in this bizarre upset.
Most Surprising Result: Savannah St. 16, Bethune-Cookman 10 (OT) - This could end up being Savannah State's first win over a DI team that finished with a winning record since 2001.
Ranking the conferences for I-AA OOC wins
So-Con: 9-0
CAA: 15-4
MVFC: 14-5
Big Sky: 9-4
Big South: 7-5
Ivy: 6-6
Patriot 10-12
OVC: 5-7
NEC: 7-10
Southland: 1-3
Pioneer: 1-15
MEAC: 0-8
SWAC: 0-3
Last edited by BDKJMU on Wed Sep 28, 2016 3:37 pm, edited 1 time in total.
JMU Football:
4 Years FBS: 40-11 (.784). Highest winning percentage & least losses of all of G5 2022-2025.
Sun Belt East Champions: 2022, 2023, 2025
Sun Belt Champions: 2025
Top 25 ranked: 2022, 2023, 2025
CFP: 2025
Fixed it. I should have had the MEAC and Pioneer flipped if going by winning percentage:
So-Con: 9-0
CAA: 15-4
MVFC: 14-5
Big Sky: 9-4
Big South: 7-5
Ivy: 6-6
Patriot 10-12
OVC: 5-7
NEC: 7-10
Southland: 1-3
Pioneer: 1-15
SWAC: 0-3
MEAC: 0-8
JMU Football:
4 Years FBS: 40-11 (.784). Highest winning percentage & least losses of all of G5 2022-2025.
Sun Belt East Champions: 2022, 2023, 2025
Sun Belt Champions: 2025
Top 25 ranked: 2022, 2023, 2025
CFP: 2025
BDKJMU wrote:Ranking the conferences for I-AA OOC wins
So-Con: 9-0
CAA: 15-4
MVFC: 14-5
Big Sky: 9-4
Big South: 7-5
Ivy: 6-6
Patriot 10-12
OVC: 5-7
NEC: 7-10
Southland: 1-3
Pioneer: 1-15
MEAC: 0-8
SWAC: 0-3
Considering the disparity in FCS talent from conference to conference that's about as valuable as ...dare I say...tits on a boar?
Not really. The top 4 conferences are certainly the Top 4- you could quibble over order. The bottom 3 are certainly the bottom 3- you'd have to put the non scholly Pioneer at the bottom.
Throw out the Southland because of only 4 games & I'd say the middle 5 (Big South through NEC) look about right..
Massey has it almost the same. Their top 5 are the same except MVFC at top, middle 5 the same (sleightly diff order) and bottom 3 are the same..
1. MVFC
2. So-Con
3. CAA
4. Big Sky
5. Big South
6. Ivy
7. OVC
8. Southland
9. Patriot
10. NEC
11. MEAC
12. SWAC
13. Pioneer http://masseyratings.com/cf/compare1aa.htm
Sagarin has it very similar:
1. MVFC
2. So-Con
3. CAA
4. Big Sky
5. OVC
6. IVY
7. Big South
8. Patriot
9. Southland
10. NEC
11. SWAC West
12. MEAC
13. Pioneer
14. SWAC East http://www.sagarin.com/sports/cfsend.htm
JMU Football:
4 Years FBS: 40-11 (.784). Highest winning percentage & least losses of all of G5 2022-2025.
Sun Belt East Champions: 2022, 2023, 2025
Sun Belt Champions: 2025
Top 25 ranked: 2022, 2023, 2025
CFP: 2025
kalm wrote:
Considering the disparity in FCS talent from conference to conference that's about as valuable as ...dare I say...tits on a boar?
Not really. The top 4 conferences are certainly the Top 4- you could quibble over order. The bottom 3 are certainly the bottom 3- you'd have to put the non scholly Pioneer at the bottom.
Throw out the Southland because of only 4 games & I'd say the middle 5 (Big South through NEC) look about right..
Massey has it almost the same. Their top 5 are the same except MVFC at top, middle 5 the same (sleightly diff order) and bottom 3 are the same..
1. MVFC
2. So-Con
3. CAA
4. Big Sky
5. Big South
6. Ivy
7. OVC
8. Southland
9. Patriot
10. NEC
11. MEAC
12. SWAC
13. Pioneer http://masseyratings.com/cf/compare1aa.htm
Sagarin has it very similar:
1. MVFC
2. So-Con
3. CAA
4. Big Sky
5. OVC
6. IVY
7. Big South
8. Patriot
9. Southland
10. NEC
11. SWAC West
12. MEAC
13. Pioneer
14. SWAC East http://www.sagarin.com/sports/cfsend.htm
Yes really.
Computers, especially right now...yawn.
The CAA at least has 4 nice wins, UVA, UND, Buff, and Colgate. The rest are the likes of Hampton, DSU, etc.
And other than UCA, what are the SoCon's quality wins?
I'm not saying that UTC, Cit, JMU, and Rich aren't really good teams but the conference OOC records are rather skewed.
