Championship Subdivision Football | FCS Football | Stadiums | Blogs | Forums

Based on the end of the season rankings, indicate who you think would win each game through to the end.

North:
#16 Jacksonville State @ #1 Villanova
#9 Elon @ #8 South Carolina State Univ.

MidWest:
#12 McNeese St. @ #5 Richmond
#13 Eastern Washington @ #4 William & Mary

West:
#15 Prarie View A&M @ #2 Montana
#10 Stephen F. Austin @ #7 New Hampshire

South:
#11 South Dakota State Univ @ #6 Southern Illinois
#14 Holy Cross @ #3 Appalachain State.

this is basically a redux of the playoffs on paper. but i'll try.

First Round:
Nova over JSU
SC State over Elon
McNeese over Richmond
W&M over EWU
Montana over PV A&M
SFA over UNH
SD State over SIU
App State over HC

Quarters:
Nova over SC State
W&M over McNeese
SFA over Montana
SD State over App

Semis:
Nova over W&M
SD State over SFA

Finals:
Nova over SD State

North:
#16 Jacksonville State @ #1 Villanova
#9 Elon @ #8 South Carolina State Univ.

MidWest:
#12 McNeese St. @ #5 Richmond
#13 Eastern Washington @ #4 William & Mary

West:
#15 Prarie View A&M @ #2 Montana
#10 Stephen F. Austin @ #7 New Hampshire

South:
#11 South Dakota State Univ @ #6 Southern Illinois
#14 Holy Cross @ #3 Appalachain State.

Round two
Nova over Elon
W&M over Richmond
Montana over UNH
Appy State over SDSU

Semifinals
Nova over W&M
Montana over Appy

Finals
Nova over Montana

DSUrocks07 wrote:this is basically a redux of the playoffs on paper. but i'll try.

Quarters:
Nova over SC State
W&M over McNeese
SFA over Montana
SD State over App

Semis:
Nova over W&M
SD State over SFA

Finals:
Nova over SD State

Unless this hadn't happened, SFA might have only had 5 turnovers and lost 38-7. They treated the Montana trip like a bowl game.

DSUrocks07 wrote:...SFA over Montana...

Exactly what happened in the 51-0 beatdown that SFA got in real life that makes you think they could win the second time around?

DSUrocks07 wrote:this is basically a redux of the playoffs on paper. but i'll try.

Quarters:
Nova over SC State
W&M over McNeese
SFA over Montana
SD State over App

Semis:
Nova over W&M
SD State over SFA

Finals:
Nova over SD State

Unless this hadn't happened, SFA might have only had 5 turnovers and lost 38-7. They treated the Montana trip like a bowl game.

#16 Jacksonville State @ #1 Villanova
#9 Elon @ #8 South Carolina State Univ.
#12 McNeese St. @ #5 Richmond
#13 Eastern Washington @ #4 William & Mary
#15 Prarie View A&M @ #2 Montana
#10 Stephen F. Austin @ #7 New Hampshire
#11 South Dakota State Univ @ #6 Southern Illinois
#14 Holy Cross @ #3 Appalachain State

Nova > SCSt
W&M > McNeese
Montana > UNH
SDSU > AppSt

Nova > W&M
Montana > SDSU

Nova > Montana

wait, haven't we already had that?

BTW, quite a few of those teams won't be in the Post-Season this year.

nwFL Griz wrote:

DSUrocks07 wrote:...SFA over Montana...

Exactly what happened in the 51-0 beatdown that SFA got in real life that makes you think they could win the second time around?

GeauxLions94 wrote:
Unless this hadn't happened, SFA might have only had 5 turnovers and lost 38-7. They treated the Montana trip like a bowl game.

They wouldn't look at this as a "bowl game" this time around. And I would think that the loss of Hauck would have an effect as well.

89Hen wrote:BTW, quite a few of those teams won't be in the Post-Season this year.

Everyone knows we would lose in the first round against whoever

DSUrocks07 wrote:

nwFL Griz wrote:
Exactly what happened in the 51-0 beatdown that SFA got in real life that makes you think they could win the second time around?

GeauxLions94 wrote:
Unless this hadn't happened, SFA might have only had 5 turnovers and lost 38-7. They treated the Montana trip like a bowl game.

They wouldn't look at this as a "bowl game" this time around. And I would think that the loss of Hauck would have an effect as well.

Would you have predicted a DSU win over Delaware if they had played in game 1 two seasons ago?

Silenoz wrote:Everyone knows we would lose in the first round against whoever

Only if you were on the road.

89Hen wrote: Only if you were on the road.

aka - czar of ECB....crackin' me up 89

89Hen wrote:

Silenoz wrote:Everyone knows we would lose in the first round against whoever

Only if you were on the road.

In the first round? Preposterous

A preseason NITbased on last year's rankings when this year (next season) most teams will be way different? How retarded.

nwFL Griz wrote:

DSUrocks07 wrote:...SFA over Montana...

Exactly what happened in the 51-0 beatdown that SFA got in real life that makes you think they could win the second time around?

Have you ever heard of ECB?

Screamin_Eagle174 wrote:Have you ever heard of ECB?

SFA is on the east coast?

100 or so miles to the Gulf of Mexico = Atlantic = East Coast Bias


Bulletproof, like all my arguments

BDKJMU wrote:A preseason NITbased on last year's rankings when this year (next season) most teams will be way different? How retarded.

Now......now.....now....it's okaaaaayyyyyyyy.

I know JMU was not in the top 16 last season, nor the top 20 had Iused the expanded format. Don't worry though, one year, they will be back in the playoff hunt, and you could play then. But, if you happen to have a little time on your hand, go ahead, take a chance, and pick from the 16 teams who would win.

I'll help you wrap your mind around trying this. First remember, this is all fictional. You could never have a Pre-Season NIT in football. Thus, you have nothing to lose by trying to guess who would win through to the end. And yes, all of the FCS football teams will be different in 2010. Kids will sign LOI's next week, kids will xfer throughout the spring and summer. Kids will become academically ineligible. Kids will become parents and drop out of school, kids will get injured in the spring and summer. Coaches will come and go. A lot of things will happen.

But until then, try and live a little. Retarded???

89Hen wrote:

Screamin_Eagle174 wrote:Have you ever heard of ECB?

SFA is on the east coast?

That prediction that Montana would lose was made in this case by a Delaware fan...

Screamin_Eagle174 wrote:

89Hen wrote: SFA is on the east coast?

That prediction that Montana would lose was made in this case by a Delaware fan...

HEY HEY HEY!!!!!!!!!!!!

I resent being associated with "that school up north"

Im sorry fellow CS'ers. I had no idea that Montana would be returning all of their graduated seniors and that Coach Hauck would be on the sidelines for this tournament...my apologizes, it won't happen again.

jstclmet wrote:

BDKJMU wrote:A preseason NITbased on last year's rankings when this year (next season) most teams will be way different? How retarded.

Now......now.....now....it's okaaaaayyyyyyyy.

I know JMU was not in the top 16 last season, nor the top 20 had Iused the expanded format. Don't worry though, one year, they will be back in the playoff hunt, and you could play then. But, if you happen to have a little time on your hand, go ahead, take a chance, and pick from the 16 teams who would win.

I'll help you wrap your mind around trying this. First remember, this is all fictional. You could never have a Pre-Season NIT in football. Thus, you have nothing to lose by trying to guess who would win through to the end. And yes, all of the FCS football teams will be different in 2010. Kids will sign LOI's next week, kids will xfer throughout the spring and summer. Kids will become academically ineligible. Kids will become parents and drop out of school, kids will get injured in the spring and summer. Coaches will come and go. A lot of things will happen.

But until then, try and live a little. Retarded???

Yes. Its retarded.

Screamin_Eagle174 wrote:

89Hen wrote: SFA is on the east coast?

That prediction that Montana would lose was made in this case by a Delaware fan...

A DelSt fan, but what does that have to do with it anyway? SFA is not even close to an east coast team.

My actual prediction is that they'd both lose.