Championship Subdivision Football | FCS Football | Stadiums | Blogs | Forums

Poll results time! Here's mine:

1. Villanova
2. Montana
3. Southern Illinois
4. William and Mary
5. Richmond
6. Appalachian State
7. South Carolina State
8. Northern Iowa
9. McNeese State
10. Elon
11. Eastern Washington
12. Stephen F. Austin
13. New Hampshire
14. Weber State
15. Eastern Illinois
16. Holy Cross
17. South Dakota State
18. Liberty
19. Montana State
20. Prairie View A&M
21. Florida A&M
22. Colgate
23. UC Davis
24. Butler
25. Pennsylvania

26. Delaware
27. Central Connecticut State
28. Lafayette
29. Dayton

I think its Week 11 right?

1: Southern Illinois Salukis
2: Montana Grizzlies
3: Villanova Wildcats
4: Richmond Spiders
5: William & Mary Tribe
6: Appalachian State Mountaineers
7: New Hampshire Wildcats
8: South Dakota State Jackrabbits
9: Northern Iowa Panthers
10: Eastern Washington Eagles
11: Elon Phoenix
12: South Carolina State Bulldogs
13: Weber State Wildcats
14: McNeese State Cowboys
15: Eastern Illinois Panthers
16: Stephen F. Austin Lumberjacks
17: Jacksonville State Gamecocks
18: Delaware Fightin' Blue Hens
19: Liberty Flames
20: Montana State Bobcats
21: Texas State Bobcats
22: James Madison Dukes
23: Holy Cross Crusaders
24: Lafayette Leopards
25: Pennsylvania Quakers

MrTitleist wrote:Poll results time! Here's mine:

1. Villanova
2. Montana
3. Southern Illinois
4. William and Mary
5. Richmond
6. Appalachian State
7. South Carolina State
8. Northern Iowa
9. McNeese State
10. Elon
11. Eastern Washington
12. Stephen F. Austin
13. New Hampshire
14. Weber State
15. Eastern Illinois
16. Holy Cross
17. South Dakota State
18. Liberty
19. Montana State
20. Prairie View A&M
21. Florida A&M
22. Colgate
23. UC Davis
24. Butler
25. Pennsylvania

26. Delaware
27. Central Connecticut State
28. Lafayette
29. Dayton

You know that Butler got destroyed by a bad Jacksonville team this weekend right?

And?

MrTitleist wrote:And?

Every team in the big sky would beat them by two touchdowns minimum.

MrTitleist wrote:And?

And because of that I cannot see any plausible way to include them in the Top 25.

MrTitleist wrote:Poll results time! Here's mine:

1. Villanova
2. Montana
3. Southern Illinois
4. William and Mary
5. Richmond
6. Appalachian State
7. South Carolina State
8. Northern Iowa
9. McNeese State
10. Elon
11. Eastern Washington
12. Stephen F. Austin
13. New Hampshire
14. Weber State
15. Eastern Illinois
16. Holy Cross
17. South Dakota State
18. Liberty
19. Montana State
20. Prairie View A&M
21. Florida A&M
22. Colgate
23. UC Davis
24. Butler
25. Pennsylvania

26. Delaware
27. Central Connecticut State
28. Lafayette
29. Dayton

I can't give Butler any love after losing to Jacksonville. Also can't give Colgate any love without also giving Lafayette some love. My poll will come out tomorrow (Monday).

1. Southern Illinois
2. Villanova
3. Montana
4. W is M
5. Ticks
6. Appy
7. New Hampshire
8. Elon
9. South Carolina St
10. McNeese
11. Northern Iowa
12. Bunnies
13. Eastern Illinois
14. Eastern Washington
15. Mr. Austin
16. Flames of Liberty
---------------------------------
17. Weber
18. Montana St.
19. Lafayatte
20. Holy Cross
21. Prairie View A&M
22. Colgate
23. Huskie Rejects
24. Florida A&M
25. Albany

Here is mine. I almost put Nova #1 but with the way ASU dominated Elon and how they have looked over the last four weeks they are playing the best ball of anyone in the nation. I vote mostly how good I think a team is playing right now weighing the most in my vote with their overall resume second, especially in the top 5-10.

1. Appalachian State 8-2
2. Villanova 9-1
3. Southern Illinois 9-1
4. Montana 10-0
5. Richmond 9-1
6. William & Mary 9-1
7. McNeese State 8-2
8. New Hampshire 8-2
9. South Carolina State 9-1
10. Elon 8-2
11. South Dakota State 7-3
12. Northern Iowa 7-3
13. Stephen F. Austin 8-2
14. Eastern Illinois 8-2
15. Eastern Washington 7-3
16. Holy Cross 9-1
17. Jacksonville State 7-3
18. Liberty 8-2
19. Weber State 6-4
20. Prairie View A&M 7-1
21. Colgate 9-2
22. Delaware 6-4
23. Penn 7-2
24. Montana State 7-3
25. Lafayette 8-2

1. Southern Illinois
2. Villanova
3. William & Mary
4. Richmond
5. Montana
6. Appalachian St.
7. Elon
8. South Carolina St.
9. New Hampshire
10. South Dakota St.
11. Northern Iowa
12. McNeese St.
13. Eastern Illinois
14. Liberty
15. Stephen F. Austin
16. Eastern Washington
17. Montana St.
18. Holy Cross
19. Prairie View A&M
20. Jacksonville St.
21. Weber St.
22. Delaware
23. Lafayette
24. Colgate
25. Pennsylvania

danefan wrote:

MrTitleist wrote:And?

And because of that I cannot see any plausible way to include them in the Top 25.

You of all people shouldn't be criticizing any polls. After I looked at your posted poll this week and last week I'm astounded that you're allowed to vote. You had three teams in the top 10 last week that lost this week.. one of them moved down, the other two remained in their same place. You had UCD at #24 last week, and after they won this last week, you moved them out of the top 25. It makes me wonder if you're even paying attention when you do your poll.

I included Butler, and many other fringe teams (8-2, 7-3 weaker conf. teams) for the sole purpose that my 18-25 was pretty much obliterated by losses. Teams like JMU, UMass, NAU are not going to get my vote for top 25s this week because they are at 5-5, .500 teams do not belong in the top 25, IMO. They may or may not beat teams like Butler, but I'm not rewarding mediocrity. I compare this to a 7-1 Sun Belt team.. they play terrible games, but at some point, people are going to notice them and rank them.. Butler, FAMU, Penn, and Colgate fall in the same area for me. It really came down to ranking the lesser of all evils.

MrTitleist wrote:

danefan wrote:
And because of that I cannot see any plausible way to include them in the Top 25.

You of all people shouldn't be criticizing any polls. After I looked at your posted poll this week and last week I'm astounded that you're allowed to vote. You had three teams in the top 10 last week that lost this week.. one of them moved down, the other two remained in their same place. You had UCD at #24 last week, and after they won this last week, you moved them out of the top 25. It makes me wonder if you're even paying attention when you do your poll.

I included Butler, and many other fringe teams (8-2, 7-3 weaker conf. teams) for the sole purpose that my 18-25 was pretty much obliterated by losses. Teams like JMU, UMass, NAU are not going to get my vote for top 25s this week because they are at 5-5, .500 teams do not belong in the top 25, IMO. They may or may not beat teams like Butler, but I'm not rewarding mediocrity. I compare this to a 7-1 Sun Belt team.. they play terrible games, but at some point, people are going to notice them and rank them.. Butler, FAMU, Penn, and Colgate fall in the same area for me. It really came down to ranking the lesser of all evils.

I can't give Butler any love this week without giving Jacksonville some love...and I can't give Jacksonville any love at all.

Not even a small hug?

You know what's great about the polling process? We are all entitled to our own opinon!

Isn't that AWESOME!!

AZGrizFan wrote:You know what's great about the polling process? We are all entitled to our own opinon!

Isn't that AWESOME!!

Free will doesn't exist Z. Now get to goose-stepping and start following SuperHornet's method to building an accurate top 25. Starting with Liberty.

MrTitleist wrote:

AZGrizFan wrote:You know what's great about the polling process? We are all entitled to our own opinon!

Isn't that AWESOME!!

Free will doesn't exist Z. Now get to goose-stepping and start following SuperHornet's method to building an accurate top 25. Starting with Liberty.

If danefan didn't like YOUR poll, he REALLY ain't gonna like MY poll....

1) Montana
2) Villanova
3) SIU
4) William & Mary
5) App State
6) Richmond
7) UNI
8) McNeese State
9) EWU
10) Weber State
11) Elon
12) UNH
13) South Carolina State
14) EIU
15) SDSU
16) Delaware
17) SFA
18) Holy Cross
19) Montana State
20) Liberty
21) Central Connecticut St
22) Jacksonville St
23) Lafayette
24) Texas State
25) Old Dominion

MrTitleist wrote:Not even a small hug?

Not even a password to an online dating service.

Nice Z. Your 18-25 is as amusing as mine. We're going to see some funny teams in the last 7 spots. It really is up for grabs.. a lot of iffy choices to be spread around.

MrTitleist wrote:Nice Z. Your 18-25 is as amusing as mine. We're going to see some funny teams in the last 7 spots. It really is up for grabs.. a lot of iffy choices to be spread around.

Honestly, does it really matter after about 20? ODU's schedule wasn't much worse than Laughayette or Liberty....

1. SIU
2. Nova
3. Richmond
4. William and Mary
5. UNH
6. Montana
7. McNeese
8. SDSU
9. App St.
10. SCSU
11. EIU
12. UNI
13. Liberty
14. Jacksonville St.
15. EWU
16. Weber
17. Holy Cross
18. Elon
19. SFA
20. JMU
21. Penn
22. Lafayette
23. Montana State
24. ODU
25. PVAM

1: Southern Illinois Salukis
2: Villanova Wildcats
3: Richmond Spiders
4: Montana Grizzlies
5: William & Mary Tribe
6: Appalachian State Mountaineers
7: South Carolina State Bulldogs
8: New Hampshire Wildcats
9: Elon Phoenix
10: Stephen F. Austin Lumberjacks
11: McNeese State Cowboys
12: Eastern Washington Eagles
13: Northern Iowa Panthers
14: South Dakota Coyotes
15: Eastern Illinois Panthers
16: Jacksonville Dolphins
17: Liberty Flames
18: Weber State Wildcats
19: Holy Cross Crusaders
20: Montana State Bobcats
21: Texas State Bobcats
22: Delaware Fightin' Blue Hens
23: Colgate Raiders
24: UC Davis Aggies
25: Lafayette Leopards

Goddamnit. Mr T (one of you), could you fix that to JSU? I experimented with typing the teams name and then hitting tab. Worked out other than that mishap.

Screamin_Eagle174 wrote:1: Southern Illinois Salukis
2: Villanova Wildcats
3: Richmond Spiders
4: Montana Grizzlies
5: William & Mary Tribe
6: Appalachian State Mountaineers
7: South Carolina State Bulldogs
8: New Hampshire Wildcats
9: Elon Phoenix
10: Stephen F. Austin Lumberjacks
11: McNeese State Cowboys
12: Eastern Washington Eagles
13: Northern Iowa Panthers
14: South Dakota Coyotes
15: Eastern Illinois Panthers
16: Jacksonville Dolphins
17: Liberty Flames
18: Weber State Wildcats
19: Holy Cross Crusaders
20: Montana State Bobcats
21: Texas State Bobcats
22: Delaware Fightin' Blue Hens
23: Colgate Raiders
24: UC Davis Aggies
25: Lafayette Leopards

Goddamnit. Mr T (one of you), could you fix that to JSU? I experimented with typing the teams name and then hitting tab. Worked out other than that mishap.

Look, someone giving love to Jacksonville.

Oh, what the hell. My poll. This week (last week). Showing some love to Montana State, finally.

1. Southern Illinois (1)
2. Villanova (3)
3. Montana (4)
4. William & Mary (5)
5. Richmond (6)
6. Appalachian State (7)
7. South Carolina State (9)
8. Northern Iowa (10)
9. McNeese State (11)
10. Elon (2)
11. New Hampshire (8)
12. Eastern Illinois (13)
13. South Dakota State (12)
14. Weber State (14)
15. Stephen F Austin (19)
16. Delaware (15)
17. Eastern Washington (17)
18. Liberty (18)
19. Jacksonville State (20)
20. Holy Cross (21)
21. Montana State (NR)
22. Pennsylvania (25)
23. Prairie View (NR)
24. Florida A&M (16)
25. Lafayette (22)

Dropped: SE Louisiana (23), Texas State (24)

JALMOND wrote:Oh, what the hell. My poll.

You rambunctiously-spontaneous-poster you!

Screamin_Eagle174 wrote:1: Southern Illinois Salukis
2: Villanova Wildcats
3: Richmond Spiders
4: Montana Grizzlies
5: William & Mary Tribe
6: Appalachian State Mountaineers
7: South Carolina State Bulldogs
8: New Hampshire Wildcats
9: Elon Phoenix
10: Stephen F. Austin Lumberjacks
11: McNeese State Cowboys
12: Eastern Washington Eagles
13: Northern Iowa Panthers
14: South Dakota Coyotes
15: Eastern Illinois Panthers
16: Jacksonville Dolphins
17: Liberty Flames
18: Weber State Wildcats
19: Holy Cross Crusaders
20: Montana State Bobcats
21: Texas State Bobcats
22: Delaware Fightin' Blue Hens
23: Colgate Raiders
24: UC Davis Aggies
25: Lafayette Leopards

Goddamnit. Mr T (one of you), could you fix that to JSU? I experimented with typing the teams name and then hitting tab. Worked out other than that mishap.

Better ask 'em to change South Dakota to South Dakota St. while they're at it