Championship Subdivision Football | FCS Football | Stadiums | Blogs | Forums

http://www.championshipsubdivision.com/ ... ctions-112

Trying to get a little more in depth than I have in the past.

These are predictions of what I think would happened if the playoffs were drawn today, like bracketology in basketball. This is not a prognostication of what I think will happen in the coming weeks.

Seems pretty reasonable.

I don't think Delaware will be there at the end, though, since they have to play road games against Navy & Nova. That will create an even bigger mess than last year for the final spot with a slew of likely contenders: Weber, EWU, Colgate/Lafayette/Holy Cross (whoever finishes 2nd. in the PL), FAMU, Liberty, UMass, CCSU.

Good to see our traditional match against UNH on there again.

Looks pretty good Rob. As tough as the BSC is this year I can't imagine us not getting two but right now the 2nd team ain't making themselves very noticeable. Nice work.

Ursus A. Horribilis wrote:Looks pretty good Rob. As tough as the BSC is this year I can't imagine us not getting two but right now the 2nd team ain't making themselves very noticeable. Nice work.

47-10.


We're right here!!!

I don't see how you can have Delaware in there. They'd have to win out, which means beating a Navy squad that should've beaten Ohio State earlier this year. If I remember right, they had to fumble near the goal line and have OSU recover and run it back for a TD to lose that one.

Screamin_Eagle174 wrote:I don't see how you can have Delaware in there. They'd have to win out, which means beating a Navy squad that should've beaten Ohio State earlier this year. If I remember right, they had to fumble near the goal line and have OSU recover and run it back for a TD to lose that one.

It's unlikely, but far from impossible. Delaware beat bowl-bound Navy teams in '03 and '07. This Delaware team isn't quite as good as the other two, though.

You've got UNH at 2nd in the CAA. I figure that would put them at 10-1 with wins over Villanova and WM.
I'm not saying I'm predicting that, but that looks the the way you've got it.

2 questions....A 10-1 UNH is not a seed?

You really think UNH @ 10-1 would be rewarded with a trip to UNI?

yorkcountyUNHfan wrote:You've got UNH at 2nd in the CAA. I figure that would put them at 10-1 with wins over Villanova and WM.
I'm not saying I'm predicting that, but that looks the the way you've got it.

2 questions....A 10-1 UNH is not a seed?

You really think UNH @ 10-1 would be rewarded with a trip to UNI?

Or that UNI will get an at-large with their not-so-impressive resume?

I'll be honest, if App State gets to 9-2, I think they'll get the seed over UNH despite the fact that UNH would have a significantly better resume (including 3 wins better than Elon).

Do you think the committee cares about sending a 10-1 team to UNI, again? Unless UNH gets a seed they're going to a Southland/MVFC/BSC team, in all likelihood.

WrenFGun wrote:I'll be honest, if App State gets to 9-2, I think they'll get the seed over UNH despite the fact that UNH would have a significantly better resume (including 3 wins better than Elon).

Do you think the committee cares about sending a 10-1 team to UNI, again? Unless UNH gets a seed they're going to a Southland/MVFC/BSC team, in all likelihood.

They'll go with the venue every time. In '03 SIU was 10-1 or 10-2 and got sent to UD.

Not bad, at all...

I'm not that convinced the CAA will get that 5th slot this season...we've been doing a pretty good job of beating up on each other...

Question is...if the CAA doesn't get the 5th slot, where does that dance card go?????

yorkcountyUNHfan wrote:You've got UNH at 2nd in the CAA. I figure that would put them at 10-1 with wins over Villanova and WM.
I'm not saying I'm predicting that, but that looks the the way you've got it.

2 questions....A 10-1 UNH is not a seed?

You really think UNH @ 10-1 would be rewarded with a trip to UNI?

UNI would put a better offer to host out there than UNH. UNI could pull between 12-15K for that game, UNH would be 9K at most.

Mvemjsunpx wrote:Seems pretty reasonable.

I don't think Delaware will be there at the end, though, since they have to play road games against Navy & Nova. That will create an even bigger mess than last year for the final spot with a slew of likely contenders: Weber, EWU, Colgate/Lafayette/Holy Cross (whoever finishes 2nd. in the PL), FAMU, Liberty, UMass, CCSU.

I agree. This is as of today.

JayJ79 wrote:Good to see our traditional match against UNH on there again.

Yeah, that's the way the bracket fell. Why not make it 4 times in 5 years.

Ursus A. Horribilis wrote:Looks pretty good Rob. As tough as the BSC is this year I can't imagine us not getting two but right now the 2nd team ain't making themselves very noticeable. Nice work.

The BSC is tough. Montana dominates and the next 3 are up and down.

Yeah, if you're doing this as of right now, rather than predicting to the end of the year, it's tough to put anyone from the BSC in. There are three teams that, IF they win out, WILL be squarely in the discussion, however, no one right now seems to be worthy.

yorkcountyUNHfan wrote:You've got UNH at 2nd in the CAA. I figure that would put them at 10-1 with wins over Villanova and WM.
I'm not saying I'm predicting that, but that looks the the way you've got it.

2 questions....A 10-1 UNH is not a seed?

You really think UNH @ 10-1 would be rewarded with a trip to UNI?

In the end, UNH may get a seed. Richmond still plays Nova and W&M and UNH plays W&M. If UNH gets to 10-1 they would most likely earn a seed.

Col Hogan wrote:Not bad, at all...

I'm not that convinced the CAA will get that 5th slot this season...we've been doing a pretty good job of beating up on each other...

Question is...if the CAA doesn't get the 5th slot, where does that dance card go?????

I actually removed Delaware, but after running through the other teams, put them back in.

ToTheLeft wrote:Yeah, if you're doing this as of right now, rather than predicting to the end of the year, it's tough to put anyone from the BSC in. There are three teams that, IF they win out, WILL be squarely in the discussion, however, no one right now seems to be worthy.

Maybe EWU. I basically had to pick two between Delaware, UNI, and EWU.

The NCAA likes names and $ so I went with UD and UNI.

clenz wrote:

yorkcountyUNHfan wrote:You've got UNH at 2nd in the CAA. I figure that would put them at 10-1 with wins over Villanova and WM.
I'm not saying I'm predicting that, but that looks the the way you've got it.

2 questions....A 10-1 UNH is not a seed?

You really think UNH @ 10-1 would be rewarded with a trip to UNI?

UNI would put a better offer to host out there than UNH. UNI could pull between 12-15K for that game, UNH would be 9K at most.

I completely understand that a UNI UNH match up would be at UNI unless UNH was a seed.
I've lived it...it sucked...both times...

yorkcountyUNHfan wrote:

clenz wrote: UNI would put a better offer to host out there than UNH. UNI could pull between 12-15K for that game, UNH would be 9K at most.

I completely understand that a UNI UNH match up would be at UNI unless UNH was a seed.
I've lived it...it sucked...both times...

Wasn't last year pretty fun outside of the game?

clenz wrote:UNI would put a better offer to host out there than UNH. UNI could pull between 12-15K for that game, UNH would be 9K at most.

I don't think UNI would bid based on 12-15K, especially with the current financial situation.
Their attendance for the previous 4 first round home games have been thus:
2008 vs. Maine: 8477
2007 vs UNH: 16015
2005 vs EWU: 7746
2003 vs Montana St: 10165

So given that, and the financial situation, they'd probably base their bid closer to 8-9K.
But that's just speculation on my part, I really don't know the specifics of how they bid.

FCS Update wrote:

yorkcountyUNHfan wrote:
I completely understand that a UNI UNH match up would be at UNI unless UNH was a seed.
I've lived it...it sucked...both times...

Wasn't last year pretty fun outside of the game?

Mulligans

FCS Update wrote:

ToTheLeft wrote:Yeah, if you're doing this as of right now, rather than predicting to the end of the year, it's tough to put anyone from the BSC in. There are three teams that, IF they win out, WILL be squarely in the discussion, however, no one right now seems to be worthy.

Maybe EWU. I basically had to pick two between Delaware, UNI, and EWU.

The NCAA likes names and $ so I went with UD and UNI.

EWU's remaining two are more likely than Delawares. I can't wait until we settle it on the field and prove all the doubters wrong.