Page 1 of 2
Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 8:13 am
by 89Hen
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article ... tions.html
In just a few days, San Francisco’s legislature will vote on a landmark new bill that if approved would allow city employees to undergo sex change operations on the government’s dime.
The comprehensive new program is part of the city’s universal health plan and is designed to help transgendered individuals who struggle physically and emotionally with their mismatched bodies.
If approved, San Francisco would become the first city to offer such benefits. Minnesota once had a similar program, but the government eliminated it in 1998...
Supporters of the new bill are calling this move a historic step for not just LGBT equality but for civil liberty as a whole.

Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 9:14 am
by dbackjon
Great news indeed, for those transgendered Americans.
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 10:21 am
by UNI88
89Hen wrote:http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article ... tions.html
In just a few days, San Francisco’s legislature will vote on a landmark new bill that if approved would allow city employees to undergo sex change operations on the government’s dime.
The comprehensive new program is part of the city’s universal health plan and is designed to help transgendered individuals who struggle physically and emotionally with their mismatched bodies.
If approved, San Francisco would become the first city to offer such benefits. Minnesota once had a similar program, but the government eliminated it in 1998...
Supporters of the new bill are calling this move a historic step for not just LGBT equality but for civil liberty as a whole.

I understand the feeling of puzzlement about why a gender change operation s/b covered but I can also understand it from the other perspective. Yes a gender change operation is elective similar to something like Lasik but there is probably a huge difference from being insulted/hurt because someone calls you "four eyes" to feeling completely out of place in your own body. A gender change operation could do more to make a person feel at peace with themselves than any amount of therapy.
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 10:27 am
by 89Hen
UNI88 wrote:I understand the feeling of puzzlement about why a gender change operation s/b covered but I can also understand it from the other perspective.
I can understand WHY the other perspective would want it covered, but how in the world can you justify an employer picking this up? I'd have no problem if a private company wanted to pick this up, but NOT a municipality.

Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 10:28 am
by 89Hen
dbackjon wrote:Great news indeed, for those transgendered Americans.
No doubt. And horrible news for everyone else.
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 10:31 am
by Grizalltheway
89Hen wrote:dbackjon wrote:Great news indeed, for those transgendered Americans.
No doubt. And horrible news for everyone else.
Get over it. If a majority of San Fran taxpayers are okay with it, WGAF?

Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 10:52 am
by MSUDuo
Grizalltheway wrote:89Hen wrote:
No doubt. And horrible news for everyone else.
Get over it. If a majority of San Fran taxpayers are okay with it, WGAF?

Then let the ones who are ok with it pay for it.
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 10:55 am
by 89Hen
Grizalltheway wrote:If a majority of San Fran taxpayers are okay with it, WGAF?

Are they?
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 10:58 am
by Grizalltheway
89Hen wrote:Grizalltheway wrote:If a majority of San Fran taxpayers are okay with it, WGAF?

Are they?
I wouldn't be surprised...at all.
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 10:59 am
by 89Hen
Grizalltheway wrote:89Hen wrote:
Are they?
I wouldn't be surprised...at all.
Then let them get further in debt.

Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:00 am
by death dealer
I think it's great if someone who thinks they'd rather be a different sex than they were born genetically can go and get a pseudo sex change (because that ultimately is what we are talking about here. Genetically, they are still a man or woman, and cutting off or adding on an appendage doesn't change that). However, I do have to fall on 89's side of the line on this one. It is elective surgery, and should not be covered by insurance anymore than porcelain veneers or a face lift.

Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:00 am
by Grizalltheway
MSUDuo wrote:Grizalltheway wrote:
Get over it. If a majority of San Fran taxpayers are okay with it, WGAF?

Then let the ones who are ok with it pay for it.
Sure thing, but we'll also have to make sure the people who didn't vote to legalize marijuana here in WA don't benefit from all of the new tax revenue.

Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:15 am
by CAA Flagship
UNI88 wrote:
I understand the feeling of puzzlement about why a gender change operation s/b covered but I can also understand it from the other perspective. Yes a gender change operation is elective similar to something like Lasik but there is probably a huge difference from being insulted/hurt because someone calls you "four eyes" to feeling completely out of place in your own body. A gender change operation could do more to make a person feel at peace with themselves than any amount of therapy.
Wow. I'm having a hard time taking that as a good enough reason to justify the public funding of the procedure. "Feel at peace with themselves"? Really?
What's next? Free tattoo removal?
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:20 am
by kalm
How expensive is the procedure and how many people will do it?
The increased productivity at work for the recipients and those they work with might pay for it.
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:28 am
by BlueHen86
death dealer wrote:I think it's great if someone who thinks they'd rather be a different sex than they were born genetically can go and get a pseudo sex change (because that ultimately is what we are talking about here. Genetically, they are still a man or woman, and cutting off or adding on an appendage doesn't change that). However, I do have to fall on 89's side of the line on this one. It is elective surgery, and should not be covered by insurance anymore than porcelain veneers or a face lift.

I agree.
We have a spending problem in this country. There are certain things that we can't afford to spend money on, even if we wanted too. Elective surgery falls into this category.
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:31 am
by CAA Flagship
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:31 am
by Grizalltheway
BlueHen86 wrote:death dealer wrote:I think it's great if someone who thinks they'd rather be a different sex than they were born genetically can go and get a pseudo sex change (because that ultimately is what we are talking about here. Genetically, they are still a man or woman, and cutting off or adding on an appendage doesn't change that). However, I do have to fall on 89's side of the line on this one. It is elective surgery, and should not be covered by insurance anymore than porcelain veneers or a face lift.

I agree.
We have a spending problem in this country. There are certain things that we can't afford to spend money on, even if we wanted too. Elective surgery falls into this category.
If this were happening on a federal level, I would agree with you guys. But it's California; they're going broke anyway, who cares if they snip a few dicks on the way down?
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:35 am
by CAA Flagship
Grizalltheway wrote:BlueHen86 wrote:
I agree.
We have a spending problem in this country. There are certain things that we can't afford to spend money on, even if we wanted too. Elective surgery falls into this category.
If this were happening on a federal level, I would agree with you guys. But it's California; they're going broke anyway, who cares if they snip a few dicks on the way down?
The Federal Govt will bail them out. Are you upset at the automakers and the banks for their reckless business decisions that led to failure? Why would you not oppose this then?
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:45 am
by 93henfan
I'm with the Conks on this one.
Ever since my (COONT!) ex-wife got my insurance to pay for her boob redux I have been opposed to these elective procedures.

Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:54 am
by CAA Flagship
93henfan wrote:I'm with the Conks on this one.
Ever since my (COONT!) ex-wife got my insurance to pay for her boob redux I have been opposed to these elective procedures.


"Before" Pics or STFU.
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 11:54 am
by Chizzang
93henfan wrote:I'm with the Conks on this one.
Ever since my (COONT!) ex-wife got my insurance to pay for her boob redux I have been opposed to these elective procedures.

Yeah...
This is elective surgery
We can get into all the micro-details and what-if's and conjecture
But in the end it's elective surgery and that shouldn't be covered by tax payers (anywhere)
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 12:02 pm
by 89Hen
Now, if we're talking about allowing these proceedures to be covered by a flexible spending account... as long as other proceedures like breast enhancement, laser eye, etc... are allowed, this should be allowed too.
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 12:02 pm
by D1B
89Hen wrote:http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article ... tions.html
In just a few days, San Francisco’s legislature will vote on a landmark new bill that if approved would allow city employees to undergo sex change operations on the government’s dime.
The comprehensive new program is part of the city’s universal health plan and is designed to help transgendered individuals who struggle physically and emotionally with their mismatched bodies.
If approved, San Francisco would become the first city to offer such benefits. Minnesota once had a similar program, but the government eliminated it in 1998...
Supporters of the new bill are calling this move a historic step for not just LGBT equality but for civil liberty as a whole.

More hatred from the catholic.
Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 12:03 pm
by 89Hen
D1B wrote:More hatred from the catholic.
Love your consistency.

Re: Finally, equality!
Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2012 12:07 pm
by D1B
89Hen wrote:D1B wrote:More hatred from the catholic.
Love your consistency.

What would Jesus do?
If a suffering man in a woman's body asked jesus for help, what would he do? He would snap his fingers and she would be he.
If you want to be catholic, you have to walk the talk, Hen, and quit being such a hypocrit.