Agreed. It depends on whether we're talking about what should happen or what we think the committee will do which is anyone's guess.89Hen wrote:I'm more about wins over quality teams than losses... as long as there aren't several of them. Everyone is allowed to lay an egg once a year.Gil Dobie wrote:
NAU's only Big Sky wins were Weber St and 1-9 SUU.
EWU, Weber, and SDSU have similar resume's regarding quality wins and SOS. EWU has the best margin of victory followed by SDSU, with Weber quite a ways behind. EWU also has the best signature win with Davis, Weber has the next best with EWU and SDSU has a 6-4 ISUb or Montana State. Weber also has the bad loss. Unless you're giving SDSU the benefit of the doubt with their cancelled game against a 6-3 Iowa State. I'm not saying they deserve for it to be assumed a loss but it at least should be a minor knock in the comparison. Weber can hang their hat on the h2h with EWU which is favored by the committee.
What it should be...and it's closest between Weber and EWU is:
2. EWU
3. Weber
4. SDSU
But we've seen the committee tend to favor lofty records from weak conference so KSU has a decent chance to sneak in their somewhere and yes Colgate has an equally good case except KSU's run to the quarters last year probably helps them over the hump. Both of their schedules are garbage.
5. Kennesaw
6. Davis
7. Colgate
8. Winner of JMU or Towson.
Who would the second CAA be and why? It won't be Maine since they avoided JMU, Elon and SBU plus losses to Yale and W&M. Perhaps Delaware with wins over Towson and Elon? SBU has only one quality win over UD.